5 ms·
Myths about Wall Street pay days
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- wynand 17y ago"With the job market like it is, Wall Street doesn't need to pay huge bonuses to retain key people." Excuse the trollish appearance of this remark, but it's something that I've been wondering about for a long time... The world to me seems to be brimming with talented people - more than enough to fill trading firms many times over. What makes these individuals so special to warrant such huge salaries? If it's not survivorship bias, then what is it? It could be that I just don't want to admit the reality, but if it is, please tell me why I'm wrong (preferably if you're impartial to the financial world).
- pchristensen 17y agoLots of churn brings people in and out, and the potential for high salaries act as a beacon that draws many talented people to the industry who would otherwise have done something more fulfilling. They're much more about recruiting and marketing than rewarding performance. See also Freakonomics about drug dealers and McDonalds for a more detailed explanation.
- dtap 17y agoWhile there a lot of talented people, there are few extremely talented people. It is these extremely talented people who make the huge salaries. I am at a top 5 business school now and you can definitely see the future millionaires. Generally, there are a lot of people who go into finance and will make $65-70k and never get into the extreme. But there are people who are going to make $200k+ out of undergrad and likely earn millions someday. They are worth it, many already manage their own money in excess of half a mil. In a class of 300 top students, I think there are 2-3 of these people.
- thetrumanshow 17y agoI kind of see the value of raw talent/intelligence as approaching a limit. Like this graph: http://www.mar.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/science/acon/GIFs/data_dialog3_XYgraph2.png http://www.mar.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/science/acon/GIFs/data_dialog3_... The commenter's idea seems to sync with this notion, as the really talented people kind of group near the top of the curve. This would mean that they are all intelligent/talented enough to master eachother's job. I bet there is a great deal of luck involved in the outlier cases... which you seem to be attributing to talent alone.
- RyanMcGreal 17y ago> What makes these individuals so special to warrant such huge salaries? Competition for executive positions is a classic winner-take-all market. http://www.thefreelibrary.com/It%27s+a+winner-take-all+market.-a017828362 http://www.thefreelibrary.com/It%27s+a+winner-take-all+marke...
- potatolicious 17y agoBecause unlike, say, rocket science, painting, music, or programming, banking is a largely unfulfilling, yet incredibly stressful job. Without the gigantic and absurd financial incentives there's really no reason to get into it. I went to school in engineering and knew more than a few people who went to Wall Street because of the pay (and social status, since our society worships bankers and the ground upon which they tread). I'm not proud to admit it, but there was schadenfreude when the banking industry collapsed - most of these engineers-gone-Wall-Street are still as of yet unemployed. They spent their time dreaming about big money and not enough on, oh, being capable engineers... so now they're stuck up shit creek.
- jwesley 17y ago"Talent" in finance is not equal to raw skill and intelligence. A great deal of an bank employee's value is connections across the finance industry and access to inside information. While there are many highly intelligent people in the world, there are very few who have the requisite experience and domain expertise within different segments of the finance industry to attract millions (possibly billions) of dollars in new business to their company or make a similar amount trading.
- kp212 17y agoWhat a joke. I can't believe someone would actually go out and say, "In a number of cases, however, these risk-management systems were totally inadequate in the face of the market tsunami that enveloped mortgage-backed securities after home prices began to drop in 2006. The storm carried away several firms, but others performed well despite the difficulties. It wasn't the bonuses that brought everything down; it was a combination of many things, some sloppy or foolish, and most far more important than bonus checks. " as a justification for the bonuses. *Guess he forgot the fact we bailed out Citi and AIG, I guess he forgot the fact we are on the hook for that, not the firms who had the so called," these risk-management systems were totally inadequate in the face of the market tsunami". The people that built these inadequate systems still for the most part have a job, and from what I read last month the bonuses are back. Update - Just checked out his bio, Harvard MBA, career at Goldman Sachs, definitely not part of the boys club, riiight.
- rauljara 17y agoThis article doesn't really seem to acknowledge the fact that many executives have, and continue to be, compensated incredibly well for very incredibly poor performance. If the system that most companies have right now were working, that wouldn't be the case. Compensation is so high that people latch on to any reason they can find to justify it, otherwise they have to admit that they are giving people millions of dollars they don't need to. The argument the argument makes that companies need to pay so much money to maintain top talent seems like an argument in favor of regulation. If compensation were capped and merely exorbitant levels, perhaps it would be easier for companies to retain their talent. But a bigger benefit would be that companies would have an easier time telling who their top talent is, because they would not have to go through the psychologically painful process of admitting that they could have found another talented person for significantly less.
- fizx 17y ago> This article doesn't really seem to acknowledge the fact that many executives have, and continue to be, compensated incredibly well for very incredibly poor performance. Think of it like being the coach of the St. Louis Rams. Your team performs poorly, and you get paid well. Ultimately, if it's your fault, firing makes more sense than a pay cut. > The argument the argument makes that companies need to pay so much money to maintain top talent seems like an argument in favor of regulation. If there's a salary cap, then they might lose some top talent to startups (or the legal profession, or ...). Devil's advocate.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoIf Wall Street executives are truly overpaid for the profit they produce, you don't have to complain -- you can just profit from it! Simply short Goldman Sachs (which pays its employees far more than anyone else) and buy shares of a smaller bank. That way, instead of feeling like the world is unjust, you can feel like there are popular misconceptions which you can simultaneously profit from (when Goldman's price drops because it's overpaying employees) and alleviate (Goldman drops when you short it; the bank whose shares you buy goes up). And of course, you get a boost to your argument. It's going to sound less like "I resent people who can make more money than me," and more like "I think there's an economic inefficiency here -- and I'm prepared to stake money on whether or not I'm right."
- jfoutz 17y ago1. The Wall Street bonus culture led to the financial crisis. "The crisis was caused by a combination of lax monetary policy, loose regulation..., ... institutional investors ... global banking industry..." Aside from lax monetary policy, these causes are only exacerbated by huge bonuses. 2. Wall Street is totally indifferent to Main Street. Yeah... looking down main street I don't see a lot of large corporations or financial institutions ready to trade. Swing by BofA and pick up a small business loan. Not that they should be. and investor's job is to find the best possible deal. maybe it's no main street, maybe not. but technically you ought to be indifferent if you're good at investing. 3. With the job market like it is, Wall Street doesn't need to pay huge bonuses to retain key people. If you can't figure out what <key person> does to make all that money, you are not smart enough to keep that money. Since you are not smart enough, why don't the taxpayers just fund <key person> instead? What are you bringing to the table? phones and bloomberg terminals? 4. Wall Street will never restrict its own pay. Yes, clearly with all the laws and contracts requiring it, wall street will restrict its own pay. 5. Wall Street pay is so out of line, only the government can fix it. The first goddamn argument was "lax regulation" WTF?