3 ms·
Bad idea. Some consequences: * People would stop voting. * Crime would probably increase. * People would be less friendly/helpful to strangers in large citi
by amichail 17y ago
Bad idea. Some consequences:
* People would stop voting.
* Crime would probably increase.
* People would be less friendly/helpful to strangers in large cities.
* People would be less willing to drive (causing chaos in cities without sufficient public transportation).
* People would no longer care about environmental issues.
* Entrepreneurship would decrease.
* Stock trading would decrease.
- chollida1 17y agoAre you sure you replied to the correct story. This story is about teaching more statistics and less calculus to students as it is vastly more practical for them.
- amichail 17y agoThese are consequences of a greater understanding of probability and statistics.
- crux_ 17y agoNo, not really. You seem to be assuming that a greater understanding of probability would lead to decision-making that takes only probabilities into account and not, say, one's morality. But that's a ridiculous thing to assume.
- chipsy 17y agoFollowing the same "logic" you have: * People would follow healthier lifestyles. * People would avoid gambling. * People would avoid bad marriages. * The government would be more efficient. An understanding of statistics wouldn't realistically change all of these things. In practice, people can always be swayed by a powerful rhetoric, emotions, and cultural habit. Statistics lend more weight to arguments, but only a tiny fraction of people will go back and verify a statistic for accuracy.
- amichail 17y agoLosing democracy is a big deal though. While it is true that many people vote due to social pressure, I suspect that this social pressure would decrease with a better understanding of probability and statistics. You could try mandatory voting, but people could just vote randomly to avoid wasting any time thinking about the matter.
- dantheman 17y agoI disagree, I think once people understood voting they would be much less tolerant of the government acting in anyway and would require massive majorities to get anything done.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe vast majority of stock trading is institutional. Do you really believe that Morgan Stanley or Citigroup suffer from a lack of understanding of statistics?
- req2 17y agoYour argument follows the same form as the one that says a world without a god is full of evil. You overextrapolate from an overstated initial cause, and offer no evidence whatsoever for any of your bald assertions.
- Zaak 17y agoThe rational reason to vote is not because your vote actually has an effect on the election's outcome. Rather, it is because if nearly no one voted, then politicians would have no incentive to take care of the needs of the people. The reason why representative democracy works (when it does work) is because the people have the power to remove politicians from office (or prevent their reelection). Of course, it is unwise to limit your involvement in government to merely voting, but that is a separate topic.
- amichail 17y agoThis is a question about how much influence an individual has on others in terms of networking effects. Moreover, it may be sufficient to have a positive attitude toward voting without actually ever voting.
- Zaak 17y ago> Moreover, it may be sufficient to have a positive attitude toward voting without actually ever voting. Nice. Sort of like an election typhoid mary. > This is a question about how much influence an individual has on others in terms of networking effects. I agree that the influence an individual has on his social contacts is relevant here. However, I still insist that the individual's decision to vote is itself important.
- btilly 17y agoActually there is no rational reason for you, personally, to vote. However voting is a level of commitment that is sufficiently small that many are willing to put the effort out to be heard. And yes, I do vote.
- Zaak 17y ago> Actually there is no rational reason for you, personally, to vote. [snip] > And yes, I do vote. You believe there is no rational reason for you to vote, yet you vote anyway? So you believe that acting irrationally is a good thing to do? I can see how we might differ in opinion about what is the rational action in a given situation, but I have a hard time understanding how we can agree on the correct action to take, but disagree as to its rationality.