3 ms·
Spinning a lack of reversible transactions as being a "Benefit" is disingenuous because there is real demand for them. You're can't always do business with tru
by bduerst 12y ago
Spinning a lack of reversible transactions as being a "Benefit" is disingenuous because there is real demand for them. You're can't always do business with trusted merchants like Amazon, especially internationally.
The point for #3 is that "How can I use these bitcoins I've been gifted?" is not a real problem for the majority of people. It's a solution to a problem that many don't have.
I'm glad you found my story cute, but fail to see how pointing out imperfections in credit card insurance policies is supporting bitcoin, because bitcoin doesn't fill those imperfections. In fact, even with imperfections, using credit cards are still better than getting my account hacked on a bitcoin exchange.
Bitcoin transactions are also not immediate as you say they are. The entire world's supply of bitcoin is limited to 2.7 transactions a second, meaning if 10 million people used bitcoin, they would only be able to do 1 transaction every 43 days [1].
I'm not even going to go into why you would compare Mt. Gox to Madoff. Madoff is an uninsured investor and in prison, Mt. Gox is an exchange and the thieves are where?
[1](https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=941331.msg10360199#msg10360199 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=941331.msg10360199#m...)
- venaoy_ 12y ago(I can't log into my venaoy HN account at the moment) > Spinning a lack of reversible transactions as being a "Benefit" is disingenuous I argue, through my examples, that reversibility is often not as important as you may think. Another data point: I am a typical American consumer and in 20 years doing probably 5,000+ credit card transactions I have never had to issue a single chargeback at all. So I know for a fact that I would be willing to use Bitcoin for its advantages. Hell, credit card fees which are passed to customers by inflating prices by ~2% probably indirectly cost me north of $20,000 over my 20 years of use. I could have saved $20,000 and I would have been totally fine with the lack of reversibility of Bitcoin. Even if I end up being scammed one day by a non-reversible $1000 Bitcoin transaction, I would still be $19,000 financially ahead with Bitcoin. > I'm glad you found my story cute, but fail to see how pointing out imperfections in credit card insurance policies is supporting bitcoin, because bitcoin doesn't fill those imperfections I point out imperfections to show you that even an imperfect system such as credit cards manage to be reasonably successful. So Bitcoin is not perfect either but, similarly, this should not prevent it from being reasonably successful. > getting my account hacked on a bitcoin exchange Bitcoin hardware wallets have a huge potential to significantly increase security for consumers. > The entire world's supply of bitcoin is limited to 2.7 transactions a second Why do you present this as being a sort of fatal flaw? It's not. A block size increase will solve this. It was not done yet because it's not a problem yet: the average block size is currently still far below the 1MB limit. > I'm not even going to go into why you would compare Mt. Gox to Madoff. Madoff is an uninsured investor and in prison, Mt. Gox is an exchange and the thieves are where? I compare the two because both cases are a result of fraud and both cases were/are being investigated by authorities. (MtGox was not robbed, Mark Karpeles committed fraud -- see the willy report -- as a result Karpeles is currently under investigation by the Japanese authorities). You seem to be under the impression the government and authorities are ignoring Bitcoin fraud. They are not. In the US for example the S.E.C. recently prosecuted a Bitcoin ponzi scheme operator: http://www.sec.gov/News/PressRelease/Detail/PressRelease/1370539730583#.VObB8k338yg http://www.sec.gov/News/PressRelease/Detail/PressRelease/137...
- bduerst 12y agoThose aren't examples, they're hypothetical stories created purposefully to support bitcoin, and border on No-True-Scotsman (A "true" payment system doesn't need dispute handling, so bitcoin is a true payment system). Pointing out imperfections in credit card insurance doesn't mean bitcoin will work. I'm sorry but even you have to realize this is not even a logical point you're making. Again, you completely missed the purpose of insurance. If your bitcoin hardware wallet is stolen, does it have insurance? Was any of the 4 exchanges hacked last week or Mt. Gox insured as your bank and payment processors are? Mt. Gox was not a ponzi scheme because it is not an investor - stop comparing it to one. >Why do you present 2.7 transactions a second as being a sort of fatal flaw? Because it is? Block size can't be increased because bitcoin is decentralized. Each miner, merchant, etc. are rational actors looking out for their own profit, and can't come to the required consensus on any changes (hence how centralized agnostic monetary controls work). It's one of the reasons other cryptocurrencies, with higher xfer rates, have a competitive edge on bitcoin. Bitcoin can not support more than a couple million users. Is this really news to you? Full disclaimer please: How much have you invested into bitcoin?
- venaoy_ 12y agoCoinbase's bitcoins are insured. And Coinbase's dollars are FDIC-insured. There is nothing inherent to Bitcoin that prevents an exchange from being operated responsibly and covered/insured just as well as traditional financial institutions. > Block size can't be increased because bitcoin is decentralized. It is not trivial, but it can be increased. What you don't understand is that all the merchants all the institutions all the individuals utilizing Bitcoins rely on its proper operation to benefit from it. If they more or less all agree that raising the block size is the obvious way to scale up, then they will agree to raise it. > Bitcoin can not support more than a couple million users. False. If the block size is increased, it can scale: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Scalability https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Scalability I invested $0 in Bitcoin. But a coworker gave me 500 BTC for free in 2010 (I never sold any).
- bduerst 12y ago