3 ms·
As for financial sector, so much money is floating around these guys that they can earn exorbitant wages almost effortlessly without having any skill at all. F
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
As for financial sector, so much money is floating around these guys that they can earn exorbitant wages almost effortlessly without having any skill at all.
Fail.
I've been through the interview process at a couple of such places, and you don't get in without having some skill.
In fact, I'd say the typical financial job is more technical than the typical engineering job. A large number of engineering jobs consist of little more than the electrical/mechanical/chemical equivalent of CRUD programming, but not very many finance jobs fall into that category [1].
[1] The financial industry requires many CRUD-type jobs to be done just like any other industry, but those are usually outsourced.
- scotty79 17y agoI overshot myself a bit with "without having any skill at all". I meant "without skill that they must had to get comparable salary from engineering type of job". Also I didn't mean CRUD jobs because they are probably same as everywhere else. Smart person with a bit of social aptitude can pass them fairly fast. I don't think that during work you would be using skills that you were tested for during interviews. Any highly profitable branch that does not require skill has to have high barrier on entry. Because if not, soon all people would d it, and that would make it less profitable. If job actually requires skill then barrier of entry need not to be so high because lack of skill will quickly become apparent anyway. For example barrier of entry to my college was fairly low (it was technical and not many people actually wanted to get in because math is hard so the college set their barriers fairly low to not put people off, this also probably had to do with the way the school was financed). Semester later one third of the students were gone. After first semester only half remained.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoAccording to the people I've spoken to working in finance, they routinely use moderately advanced math. By advanced math, I mean PDEs, numerical problems requiring cleverness and more probability than most engineers learn [1]. They also do it at a speed and level of distraction that many good techies can't handle. By this I mean a trader has the absolute right to yell at you at any time and make you drop everything debug the program he is using. As for "barriers of entry need not be so high", college is different than a job. Your college still collected tuition from the students up until they dropped out. Goldman Sachs has to pay the bad techies they recruit until they fire them (and this may also be legally problematic [2]). [1] It's usually not as deep as, e.g., a PhD in math or theoretical physics. [2] If they did as you suggest, and women or minorities disproportionately couldn't handle the job, they are inviting a disparate impact lawsuit.
- geebee 17y agoI wouldn't dispute this - I'm sure that many finance people are pretty brilliant and have very strong math backgrounds. That said, I met a lot of folks who work in finance who make a lot of money and absolutely do not have a strong math background. Of all the folks who make substantial salaries (let's say above $250K/year) on wall street, what percentage do you think could, on the spot (or within a few minutes of consulting a book or web site), solve a simple differential equation, the kind that you encounter in an upper division undergraduate math class?
- anamax 17y agoIf you really think that math is both necessary and sufficient for success in finance, get into commodities trading and show us.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoTo clarify, my claim isn't that everyone in finance (or even above a certain pay scale) has a strong math background. My claim is that many of the engineer cum quants are doing technical work (not simply paper pushing) in a difficult environment.
- geebee 17y agoI agree with you that "engineer cum quants" do hard math work, but you're not really comparing similar groups anymore (your original claim was that a "typical financial job is more technical than the typical engineering job"). My impression was that quants almost always have an academic background in math or physics, but I don't think this level of math is typical for most of the folks in finance, including many who make gobs and gobs of money.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoOops, I was unclear. I should have specified that I was comparing engineers cum quants to engineers qua engineers. (These are the two groups of people we were originally discussing.)
- anamax 17y ago> I overshot myself a bit with "without having any skill at all". I meant "without skill that they must had to get comparable salary from engineering type of job". How about some supporting evidence?
- scotty79 17y agoI'm sorry but I am not proper researcher so instead of pieces of evidence I have only experiences and thoughts most of the time. But I still want to share them with anybody interested.
- anamax 17y agoThe problem is that the above implies that you had some basis for your position. I suppose that it is okay if you don't, but is it really too much trouble to acknowledge that up front?