3 ms·
HN is, compared to the population of the West or even just the smartest 1% from which Nobelists would be drawn, a small place; on top of which, it skews young (
by gwern 12y ago
HN is, compared to the population of the West or even just the smartest 1% from which Nobelists would be drawn, a small place; on top of which, it skews young (Nobels are increasingly awarded to older people), and on top of that, I get the impression from media articles and other things that as soon as a top scientist become a Nobelist-with-a-capital-N, their already minimal free time shrinks to a size requiring an electron microscope to see.
- pilsetnieks 12y ago> Nobels are increasingly awarded to older people It was my impression that the things the Nobel prize is awarded (at least the more famous ones) are one's that were discovered when the recipient wasn't that old, just that the prize is awarded a considerable time after the discovery. After all, the discovery has to prove its importance and stand the test of time. Also, and it's pure speculation — if I were a Nobel prize laureate, I'd be able to discuss professionally interesting topics with more or less whomever I'd like, live, or in private or group correspondence, instead of a public forum.
- gwern 12y ago> It was my impression that the things the Nobel prize is awarded (at least the more famous ones) are one's that were discovered when the recipient wasn't that old It depends on the field, there's some analyses floating around about that. But the question wasn't, are there future Nobelists reading HN...