6 ms·
I'm curious what legal stance Lenovo customers have here - their secure HTTPS connections are being MITMed intentionally - surely that's hacking, or some nation
by grecy 12y ago
I'm curious what legal stance Lenovo customers have here - their secure HTTPS connections are being MITMed intentionally - surely that's hacking, or some national security violation?
- rodgerd 12y agoIt certainly seems like unauthorised use of a computer system, on the face of it.
- ajmurmann 12y agoIt's a big company doing, so it's gonna be fine.
- techtics 12y agoIt's not just because they are a big company though. The "community", the industry and the government all share blame for the lack of liability for software. Edit: It's pretty bad form to downvote new accounts becuase you disagree. Imagine if I didn't know about hellbanning. Ask yourself what open source licenses, corporate EULAs and the NSAs defense have in common. The best hope here is that Lenovo explicitly promised someone something they didn't keep.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- harbingerzero 12y agoIt actually depends whether or not the practice is directly or indirectly agreed to by the user in the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy or similar document. Now, it's likely that users do agree to it, but if the language in their policies wasn't broad enough to cover action like this, theoretically it would be a violation of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, as exceeding authorized use.
- chopin 12y agoThis won't hold for Germany though. There is a concept of surprising clause (überraschende Klausel) as well as the concept of an unethical clause (sittenwidrige Klausel). In this case I would assume that both would hold even if there is some clause in the EULA. The BigCo argument holds in Germany unfortunately as well...
- userbinator 12y agoSome EULAs basically say "you give permission for us to access and modify any data in your system"... this is the first example that comes to mind: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PunkBuster http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PunkBuster These agreements could be summed up in 3 words: "we own you".
- meowface 12y agoAt least PunkBuster is spying for a relatively noble purpose: preventing cheating in online games. Cheating absolutely destroys the experience in multiplayer games and has killed many games. This is spying with the sole purpose of spreading ads and making money.
- Alupis 12y agoSo because a few people decide to cheat at a game they paid for, everyone who paid full price for the game is forced to install spyware which can and does modify files on your pc, take screenshots as you play the game, monitor your mouse inputs, keyboard, etc...?
- meowface 12y agoI think that is fine, personally. Obviously others might not. You have to specifically agree to install/allow PunkBuster, and you can choose to play on servers that don't use PunkBuster. With Lenovo not only is there no opt-out, but you're not even aware of the adware and root CA installation. The "spyware" only spies on modifications to the game client in any way and tries to detect non-human involvement, which of course includes inspecting the file system and RAM. In theory it could harvest irrelevant information from your hard drive or memory, but no reverse engineer has ever made such a claim to my knowledge. Valve Anti-Cheat does very similar things, but is run by what many consider to be a trustworthy company, so not that many people take issue with it. If one trusts the company that distributes the spyware, it's not really a problem, in my opinion. If Valve were to ever violate that trust, it would severely harm their business. I also strongly disagree with DRM, because it only harms other players while providing no benefits. In contrast, online cheaters can completely ruin the playing experience for online games, and have heavily contributed to the death of some games. I also have no issue if people decide to cheat when in single-player mode. If you pay for the game you should be able to do whatever you want if you're not affecting others. It's only a problem when they're playing with other people over the Internet. PunkBuster and VAC only run when you're playing in online mode.
- pconner 12y ago"Adware is malware with a legal team"
- pilif 12y ago> their secure HTTPS connections are being MITMed intentionally of course they are - Lenovo customers have signed the agreement that this is ok when they started the machine the first time </sarcasm>
- redeemer 12y ago"National security" is such a fickle concept. You can bet that if the NSA manages to use this to hoover up some tasty HTTPS, this scandal will be lauded as a big boost to "national security" behind the scenes, and nobody will be punished. For all we know NSA had a hand in engineering this. Of course, if some government data is stolen as a result, then the whole thing will be thrown under the bus and deemed a threat to "national security". I hope anyone who uses terms like "national security" does it in full awareness of what Orwell meant by newspeak and doublethink.
- Alphasite_ 12y agoLenovo is a Chinese company, so it's possible, but you'd think they're more likely to be responsible.
- grey-area 12y agoIsn't superfish (or is it Phish?) a US/Israeli company? Some of the code inserted is pretty strange, including functions to checks for lenevo, bestbuy.com and isPayingCountry() with a list of country identifiers: http://pastebin.com/AQqWirba http://pastebin.com/AQqWirba So apparently they work with some big companies, and I can't work out what the country check is for, perhaps for subsidiaries of a large customer?
- heyalexej 12y agoThe code you linked is nothing out of the ordinary as far as adware in Chrome plug-ins etc. go. For an example have a look at the source code[1] of "Awesome Screenshot"[2] which is used by ~1,4M users and also calls home to 7 different hosts[3]. This is just one of many many Chrome plug-ins that is injecting ads and Google encourages this[4]. It makes sense to limit injections to markets they can serve / are affiliates in. [1] https://github.com/heyalexej/pretty-fucked-up/blob/master/bakup/similar-web-content.js https://github.com/heyalexej/pretty-fucked-up/blob/master/ba... [2] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/awesome-screenshot-captur/alelhddbbhepgpmgidjdcjakblofbmce?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/awesome-screenshot... [3] https://gist.github.com/mvirkkunen/89f61a06819530e48b53 https://gist.github.com/mvirkkunen/89f61a06819530e48b53 [4] https://developer.chrome.com/webstore/program_policies#ads https://developer.chrome.com/webstore/program_policies#ads
- vetler 12y agoIt should absolutely be illegal to do something like this.
- logfromblammo 12y agoI think what you meant to say is that the existing laws that make something like this illegal should be enforceable in a meaningful way against large manufacturers and retailers.