5 ms·
This letter - and the revenue numbers in it - are interesting from a strategy perspective. The conventional wisdom I hear is that Android owns the overall mark
by nostrademons 12y ago
This letter - and the revenue numbers in it - are interesting from a strategy perspective. The conventional wisdom I hear is that Android owns the overall market for smartphones, but if you want to make money as an independent developer, you're better off developing for iOS because iPhone users are more likely to pay for things. There's all sorts of crap in the Android ecosystem, a lot of it is free, but the users are largely the sorts of people who will take what kind of freebies they can get and don't want to pay for a premium product. By contrast, Apple actively encourages their developers to pay attention to fit & polish.
Given this, I wonder if relaxing the 30% rev split might actually be in Apple's interests. In order to build that premium ecosystem, they need developers to be able to work full-time on apps. If they strangle that ecosystem, then the only people building iPhone apps will be folks with other day jobs to support them - which means either the quality bar will go down, or their will be many fewer apps in the app store vs. Google Play.
Then again, perhaps that's Apple's plan anyway: focus on the few things that many customers want, make sure the apps for those are really good, and it's okay if there's not an app for the rest.
- throwawaymsft 12y agoRe: "owning the market", people forget the difference between market share and profit share. Profits are what keep your ecosystem alive and thriving. Raw usage numbers, by themselves, don't. (Sure, usage can lead to profits... so just measure profits!) Yes, Android sells more devices. Apple has 93% of the profits in industry, Samsung has 9%, and everyone else is fighting for that tiny slice and losing money. http://www.macrumors.com/2015/02/09/apple-mobile-profits-q4-2014/ http://www.macrumors.com/2015/02/09/apple-mobile-profits-q4-... The more profitable ecosystem is where developers want to play. Apple doesn't need to change their royalty rates, everyone is clamoring to be in that arena.
- soperj 12y agoI think you have your percentages skewed. 93 + 9 = ... Secondly how much as a percentage does Google make from mobile? Clearly it's not all about the take from people's pockets.
- mcintyre1994 12y agoI don't know the exact figures I've seen before but definitely similar - Apple and Samsung between them make more than 100% of the profit under that measurement - everyone else totalled is at a loss. Agreed about Google though, I highly doubt these figures consider their profits as a result of their position in mobile - though I guess that'd be difficult to accurately calculate.
- throwawaymsft 12y agoSee, that's the shocking thing: the other vendors are losing money. Apple makes $93, Samsung makes $9, MSFT/LG/HTC/Nokia have losses of $2.
- stormbrew 12y agoI'm pretty sure this is referring to the operating profits on hardware sales, which would be a pretty silly factor in deciding what platform to write software for. Third party software devs make precisely none of that profit. Samsung also doesn't, afaik, make any of whatever Google's cut of Android software sales are, so even if it does include app store cuts that just turns it into an apples and oranges comparison. This is not to say the conclusion is wrong, just that the data here is not relevant to it.
- throwawaymsft 12y agoAgreed, I'm using total hardware profits by ecosystem as a proxy for willingness of consumers in those ecosystems to spend money. Actual revenue from each store isn't easy to come by from what I've seen (esp. since the various Android stores are fragmented). But I think we already know the conclusion: the iOS store has more money spent in it than the Android one.
- tjl 12y agoIf you want actual app store numbers, here's a comparison from June of last year, http://www.businessinsider.com/chart-app-revenue-android-ios-2014-6 http://www.businessinsider.com/chart-app-revenue-android-ios...
- scholia 12y agoMost of Apple's profits come from hardware. In software, you should really go by software revenues. There's an installed base (units), but the installed base isn't the market, just the potential market. The market consists only of people spending money... Having said that, you need to account for all the revenues, ie not just the purchase price of an app in the store. That's an area where not everybody is happy with Apple.
- Ologn 12y agoHow many people pay to use websites? One of my side project Android apps made over $2100 in advertising revenue last month, and my other Android apps made hundreds of dollars in ad revenue. There are a number of ways people monetize Android apps - some games are freemium, and yes, some apps are paid for. I'm not unhappy with how Android monetizes.
- piyush_soni 12y agoI'm not sure why this comment was downvoted.
- bad_user 12y ago> iPhone users are more likely to pay for things. There's all sorts of crap in the Android ecosystem, a lot of it is free, but the users are largely the sorts of people who will take what kind of freebies they can get and don't want to pay for a premium product. I hear this argument a lot. I'm an Android user and as somebody that received an iPhone 6 as a gift and sold it to buy an Android, plus I also own an iPad, let me give you a counterpoint. 1) I feel the need to block ads. On Android I have Firefox which has add-ons, on iOS I don't have it. Well, you can usually find a shitty shell to iOS's webview that does. And even if the cost is non-zero, it's still shitty, not to mention untrustworthy. 2) I feel the need to view videos in any format. On Android I have VLC, the leading open-source player, OK? On iOS I don't have it (even though an implementation of VLC exists for iOS, a month ago it was pulled from the iTunes Store). Welcome to the dozens and dozens of shitty alternatives from the iTunes Store, many of which demand money for it. 3) I feel the need to listen to streaming radio. On Android I have VLC. Need I say more? 4) I feel the need to block spammy phone numbers, blocking calls, automatically deleting SMSs, plus I want regular backups, like for my SMS messages and so on and so forth. Oh wait, on iOS that's not allowed, whereas on Android I'm a paying customer. Dropbox on iOS is freaking broken, because in order to stay active in the background and sync, it needs to detect movement. 5) On Android I bought Tasker, because it's so useful at times, whereas on iOS such a thing will never be allowed. 6) I have about 8 games that I bought installed on my Android right now, even though I'm not a gamer, but it just so happens that Google Play keeps suggesting me tower defense games - whereas this doesn't happen on iOS because iTunes is restricting reviews to locals and I'm not living in the US, so all I get are suggestions for, you guessed it, shit - to search for iOS apps, I'm actually doing searches on Google. 7) Android's apps for maps are much better in my experience - besides Google Maps, I have about 3 others installed, all of them good, I only keep them around because while in roaming I don't want to be caught with poor area coverage. You're talking about iOS having "premium products", whereas the way I see it, my basic necessities are not satisfied and if I am to pay for something for iOS, it's usually in the hope that it works. And this happens primarily because of Apple's restrictions. iPhone 6 seemed to me like a really sexy phone, but I sold it anyway because of the ecosystem.
- freehunter 12y agoYeah thanks for the Android vs iOS rundown. We now all know the differences between the two, but none of the things you listed are the signatures of a premium product, merely a product that better fits your desires. Other than that, it's completely off topic.
- higherpurpose 12y agoAren't the vast majority of apps on iOS free, too?
- vacri 12y agoA minor relaxation of the 30% cut, to 25 or even 20%, won't change the bottom line for developers all that much, but cuts Apple's take by a third. In the article, the grumpy spouse who thinks $70k is not what they married into? That person isn't going to be much happier with $80k.