3 ms·
> Now, of course he has to pay for his own gas and wear and tear on his car, but he did not feel exploited. Contract law is funny. In a perfect world, anybody
by vinceguidry 12y ago
> Now, of course he has to pay for his own gas and wear and tear on his car, but he did not feel exploited.
Contract law is funny. In a perfect world, anybody should be able to make a contract with anybody else to perform a legal act for them. But the world isn't perfect. You have to take into account that the contract you just made might well be replicated hundreds, thousands, or millions of times, in countless different contexts.
Sex is legal. Forming a contract involving sex is not. Even if nine times out of ten, it's perfectly fine, that would generate huge social costs. It's why gambling is so controversial and tends to be relegated to a select few adult playgrounds that are set up to handle those costs.
Labor laws came into force awhile back to reduce the risks of employment. Before labor laws, if you got hurt on a job, it had the very real potential of ruining your life. Your employer would not pay for your care, you'd be fired, even if it was no fault of your own. And managers were often ruthless about coercing employees into performing dangerous tasks with no safety protocols. Labor laws protect you against yourself, no one should be exposed to some risks even if it means putting more food on the table.
- bkmartin 12y agoBut does that really apply in the case of Uber? Honest question. You are agreeing to perform a task, in this case, driving an individual from point A to point B for a set $ amount. You can see that dollar amount and decide to take it or not, correct? So, if you get injured in a car accident you are covered by your or the other driver's insurance. If this is a side job, not your full time work then you could have health insurance on top of that. So where exactly is the problem here? Now, this isn't speaking to the so called "gig economy" in general because I think that each company is responsible for its own rules and actions when it comes to labor. If one company fails to pay an honest wage and exploits its workers, that doesn't incriminate every company that creates a contract platform.
- vinceguidry 12y ago> So, if you get injured in a car accident you are covered by your or the other driver's insurance. Not necessarily. Most car insurance companies won't cover you if you're using your vehicle commercially unless you get a commercial policy. You could be put into the position of having nobody to foot the bill in the case of an accident. The market will eventually adjust to these new kinds of insurance customers, but if the insurance companies start catering to Uber drivers, that could cause problems for them seeing as how ride-sharing is illegal in many if not most places. So the insurance companies could be exposed to legal risk for facilitating illegal businesses, just as banks would be exposing themselves to criminal liabilities if they start catering to the marijuana industry. So they have to be careful. All increasing the risk of you getting into an accident and having no one but yourself to pay the hospital bills and getting sued by the other party or your customer for failing to carry proper insurance. The ride-sharing companies offer to shoulder the risk themselves by carrying policies, but it's unclear as to whether this is really enough.
- cplease 12y ago> Sex is legal. Forming a contract involving sex is not. Well, unless it's a marriage contract, but that's another beast altogether.
- vinceguidry 12y agoI actually looked that up while I was writing my reply. Civil marriage law in England and Wales still has a consummation requirement, but AFAIK nowhere in the US was it ever required.