4 ms·
Tell HN: Something that bothers me about discussion here.
I'm personally fascinated by debate whether or not the topic is all that reasonable.
Moreover, even if the topic is not all that reasonable now, it may be more reasonable in a decade or two and could be argued in that context.
I suppose others here think differently and don't want to debate anything that is not of practical significance today.
- icey 17y agoI'm sorry, but what are you talking about?
- amichail 17y agoSee this for example: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=905867 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=905867
- wmf 17y agoamichail likes to post philosophical questions, but many of them attract no discussion. http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=amichail http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=amichail
- nostrademons 17y agoIt's more that as you start doing things of greater complexity, the number of possible things to debate explodes exponentially, and you have to prune away fruitless discussions to avoid getting overwhelmed. Most topics have far more depth to them than is apparent at first glance, and once you start getting into them, you'll find there's a lot of interest just within a narrow specialty. If you tried to apply that same level of depth to everything that might possibly be of interest, your brain would just get overwhelmed. I used to want to discuss anything and everything too, when I was in high school. In many ways I miss that, but I also think it was largely because my life was so much more sheltered and less rich than it is now. I just wasn't exposed to all the depth in the topics I was discussing, so I needed to discuss more of them to fill up my brain. Part of the price of growing up, I guess, and one of the reasons why adults are more boring than children.
- amichail 17y agoDon't people accumulate life experience as they age thus potentially making philosophical debate more interesting?
- nostrademons 17y agoRight, but that life experience usually takes the form of greater depth and not greater breadth. One of the things that most surprised me about growing up is that I don't know more, I know better. When I was a kid, how smart you were was determined by how many facts you could remember, and how broad that knowledge was. Now, how smart I am is largely determined by how effectively I can judge whether a piece of knowledge is relevant to my particular situation. I've found that very few of the things I believed in childhood were wrong, but a great many of them were incomplete. They had little corner cases to watch out for, and situations that they didn't apply to. An interesting corollary of this is that it explains why adults always seemed so dumb to me. It's not that hard to find a random fact that most of the adults around you don't know. (It was a little depressing how often this happened in the subjects that they were teaching me, but that's another issue.) But that doesn't mean they're dumb: it means that you've stumbled into an area that just isn't that useful for them. They know a lot about their specialties, but the chance that you'd happen to be seriously interested in their specialties was pretty low. So yeah, philosophical debate is more interesting among experienced people - if you're debating things they have experience about. I think that's why most of your submissions don't get much attention; they just seem rather useless to the things that most of us here want to accomplish.
- amichail 17y agoBut many people here are attempting startups or hope to in the near future. Breadth is useful for coming up with a compelling new idea. Depth is useful for refining and implementing it. And btw, as I have aged, I have lost interest in technical things and have gained interest in more speculative/high level/philosophical matters.
- Mz 17y agoFWIW: If you are saying people aren't responding as you had hoped to things you are posting, you are the best person to do something about that. I really suck at starting threads. For the most part, I try to avoid starting too many threads because it usually goes pretty badly. At one time, I made it a specific goal to figure out how to get better at that in one forum I participated in regularly at the time. I did get better at it. One thing I did: I observed what other people did who had a track record of successfully starting conversations. I couldn't do exactly what they did but I did have a style all my own that worked reasonably well for me in that forum, at least for a time. Often, it's not simply the topic that is the problem but what the way it is framed. And if that's not what this question is about: Nevermind.