8 ms·
> Most of those conflicts are a pretense to funnel trillions of dollars into the economy It's funneling trillions of dollars into military contractors.
by baddox 12y ago
> Most of those conflicts are a pretense to funnel trillions of dollars into the economy
It's funneling trillions of dollars into military contractors.
- ceejayoz 12y agoWho are generally required by law to spend most of those dollars on American salaries and American-made products. Thus funneling them into the economy.
- fchollet 12y agoWhat who you rather get out of your tax dollars, roads and parks and fast internet, or explosives and ammo? Both mean jobs for Americans all the same. It's the value of the output that's different. Why funnel efforts and capital into military instead of funneling the same into producing infrastructure, consumer goods, and advancing science? Yes, both are contributing to "the economy". One is creating collective value, the other is enriching military contractors and creating an incentive to wage war.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y ago"Why funnel efforts and capital into military instead of funneling the same into producing infrastructure, consumer goods, and advancing science?" Because that's socialism, if not worse.
- hueving 12y agoThat's definitely not a false dichotomy. /s People funnel money into the military because they are afraid of terrorists and whatever else is the flavor of the month.
- adrianN 12y agoYou don't need many tanks to fight terrorists. Yet the army is forced to buy more tanks (against its own wishes!), because congressmen don't want the tank-production in their state to stop.
- finid 12y agoBut those terrorists they are afraid of became terrorist because of our meddling in their affairs. Ok, I know it's to "protect and defend out interests", but those interests are in somebody else's backyard and bedroom
- RickHull 12y ago> People funnel money into the military because they are afraid of terrorists and whatever else is the flavor of the month. Do you know any individuals who personally decided to funnel money into the military? It's an insatiable beast fed by political breakdown and cronyism.
- Qwertious 12y agoIt definitely isn't a false dichotomy - money spent on military ventures is money not spent on e.g. space research. What drives people to make the stupid choice is a different subject entirely.
- hueving 12y agoThat's not how federal spending works. There is no fixed amount so spending money on the military does not preclude spending money on space research. Similarly, cutting military spending doesn't mean those savings would go into any other budget.
- pkaye 12y agoThey way you funnel it into the economy makes a difference. It could also be spend on infrastructure, education, heath care.
- petersellers 12y agoBuilding bombs and guns is the economic equivalent of depression-era ditch digging (worse, in fact, since they can only be used to destroy economic output). Sure, you are paying people's salary to make them but you aren't producing anything that is a benefit to the economy.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Terr_ 12y agoNo, you're incorrectly assuming that "the economy" is a single unified whole, owned-by and benefiting a harmonious global hivemind. In reality... the door to your home has a lock on it, right? Think about the materials and effort that went into the design, manufacture, installation, and ongoing operation of that lock. Are those "wasted"? After all, it doesn't actually produce anything new! In fact, its entire purpose is to sit there and impede the flow of resources... which would otherwise flow towards people who think they can utilize them more effectively... For a more naturalistic example, what about your body's immune system? A big portion of your body's "budget" is invested in mechanisms for finding and destroying other organisms, ones which have done quite a bit of their own work to build themselves up. Do you honestly weigh the Staphylococcus economy equally to your own?
- 6d0debc071 12y agoI imagine I would find it somewhat more difficult to justify having the most heavily locked door in the world - which, by reasonable context, is closer to analogy being drawn above.
- Terr_ 12y agoI disagree with the "context" you're trying to conjure up here. Petersellers' post is quite explicit, and directly equates paying for the construction/use of weapons to paying laborers to dig/re-fill holes in the ground. At no point did he say it was disproportionate to the nation's wealth (or dirt-supply.) Rather, his post argues it shouldn't happen at all.
- baddox 12y agoYes, commercial businesses are obviously part of the economy. I was just being more specific, lest the parent comment be construed as referring to general economic stimulus.
- 3pt14159 12y agoThe economy is not some game where millions of people needlessly do actions for no purpose. We don't hire people at great expense to purposelessly move mountains between states, or rip each others hair out. The economy allocates resources. The fact that some of the wasted dollars spent on needless militarism splashes back into producing food for some of the people that were taxed in the first place isn't a goal, its a pitiful side effect. The same resources could have been used to further spaceflight, AI, public health, peace, or the environment in or outside of public spending. Warfare is a hellish waste.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> The same resources could have been used to further spaceflight, AI, public health, peace, or the environment in or outside of public spending. Warfare is a hellish waste. It's by no means perfect, but military spending has greatly benefited spaceflight, AI, public health (aid after disasters, advanced prosthetics), etc.
- ptaipale 12y agoAs a minor example we might mention the Internet, which basically grew out of projects funded by DARPA. DARPA by the way was originally started up by Eisenhower, who someone mentioned in another comment.
- nickik 12y agoWhile this is but that only looking at one part of the coin, its very hard to say what outcomes would have happend if these resources were allocated diffrently, either by markets or some other governemnt programm. The hole idea that 'lets make war and we will probebly get some side benefits out of it' is not substainable, we could have any arbitrary goal and dumb money on the problem and we will get side benefits.
- orbifold 12y agoA lot of it comes back to the broken education system in the US. The military and prison system absorb some of the least employable and underprivileged young men and women. In the case of the military it gives them a sense of purpose and pride. In the best case they either learn a trade or can go to college afterwards. And as a sibling comment points out, military spending has for the longest time been used for high technology research (Bell labs, MIT etc.).
- Chinjut 12y ago"Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed. This world in arms is not spending money alone. It is spending the sweat of its laborers, the genius of its scientists, the hopes of its children. The cost of one modern heavy bomber is this: a modern brick school in more than 30 cities. It is two electric power plants, each serving a town of 60,000 population. It is two fine, fully equipped hospitals. It is some 50 miles of concrete highway. We pay for a single fighter with a half million bushels of wheat. We pay for a single destroyer with new homes that could have housed more than 8,000 people. This, I repeat, is the best way of life to be found on the road the world has been taking. This is not a way of life at all, in any true sense. Under the cloud of threatening war, it is humanity hanging from a cross of iron. These plain and cruel truths define the peril and point the hope that come with this spring of 1953." -Dwight D. Eisenhower, in his "Chance for Peace" speech
- sobkas 12y agoIn USA, taking away money from "those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed" is a feature not a bug
- refurb 12y agoYes, that's why a huge proportion of US gov't expenditures are for entitlements. If we're trying our best not to hand out money to citizens, we're doing a pretty bad job.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- slg 12y agoNo one said it was a good or efficient jobs and stimulus program. That however doesn't change the fact that it is a jobs and stimulus program. This is most evident when looking at local politicians when a specific program is potentially being shutdown. They will fight tooth and nail regardless of the strategic necessity of the program just so they can keep the local jobs and money that that program provides.
- finid 12y agoA perfect example of trickle down economics. Was that what somebody called reaganomics?
- Evolved 12y agoThis has positive benefits such as companies like FN opening up shop stateside thus providing jobs to Americans. If I remember correctly, FN is now the largest small arms producer in the U.S. even surpassing Colt as far as supplying arms to the military and the civilian market.
- wahsd 12y agoWhat you don't quite understand is that there are inherent costs of inefficiencies of monopoly from a militaristic system like ours. Sure, all the people "employed" by defense contractors and military are funneling money into the economy, but it's so grotesquely inefficient and wasteful of a process, let along there are those huge losses for inefficiency and unnecessary management and corruption that comes with it, not even to mention that the smart guys who take a job with a defense contractor to pump out some shitty code or manage a shitty project as a result of corruption and congressional micro-management; could have developed a new technology or started a business to contribute something positive to society. What you seem to be missing is that military expenditures beyond self-defense are mostly inefficiencies. Squandered money and efforts and potential all because our form of warlords are siphoning off trillions of dollars from our economy and collective efficacy. It's really not any different than the same thing warlords to in the places you think of when I say warlord like Somalia or Afghanistan or the DR Congo; just far more sophisticated and devious in their effect.
- shitgoose 12y agoWhy not to give away these dollars to the workers then, but without building weapons? Just make sure that workers are not sitting idle and attend gym during work hours. End result is the same, whether bombs are in the storage or are not in the storage - all we see is a locked storage door anyway. As a bonus - no one gets killed by the bombs. Sigh... This Keynesian story never ends...
- refurb 12y agoAs a bonus - no one gets killed by the bombs. I don't think wars would end if we stopped spending money on the military.
- WalterBright 12y agoNot really, because the money "funneled into the economy" was first extracted from the economy.
- hueving 12y agoAnd they are a part of the economy. They have US employees who spend money.
- munificent 12y agoSure, but a very large fraction of that money goes into things that are quite literally just blown to bits. There is an actual destruction of resources.
- bmelton 12y agoConservation of energy insists that it's just a reallocation of resources. Today's landfills (and bombing targets) are tomorrow's mines. It's only when we get into nuclear materials that those resources become inviable for rediscovery.
- munificent 12y agoNo, because it's increasing entropy. In the case of explosives, one could argue the entire point is to produce maximum entropy. Which means they are effectively designed to minimize the value that can be reclaimed after they are used.