3 ms·
The PonoPlayer sounds no better than the iPhone to an untrained listener using mediocre headphones. The writer misses some important quantitative differences, b
by jdietrich 12y ago
The PonoPlayer sounds no better than the iPhone to an untrained listener using mediocre headphones. The writer misses some important quantitative differences, because he knows very little about audio engineering.
The most crucial and easily understandable difference IMO is the headphone amplifier. The iPhone has good quality digital-to-analog converters and generally sounds fine through easy to drive headphones, but it falters if you use large high-impedance headphones that need a lot of power. Hook up a pair of Sennheiser HD650s or AKG K701s to an iPhone and things go badly wrong - the bass disappears and transients start to distort, because the tiny headphone amp just doesn't have the power to cope.
Yes, the audiophile world is full of bullshit, but that doesn't mean that all quality audio products are bullshit. Professional audio engineers with degrees in physics or engineering are not fools, and they do not do critical listening through $130 headphones and whatever converter and amp happens to be on their device. They use $2000 converters, $4000 monitors and $600 headphones because they are measurably better in all sorts of ways to cheaper equipment.
If you're listening to music for pleasure, use whatever equipment you like. If you don't hear the difference that better equipment makes, then don't pay the extra. The only thing that matters is your enjoyment of the music. Conversely, just because you can't hear a difference, don't assume that it isn't there. Really understanding audio and being able to critically assess recordings and audio equipment takes a great deal of training and practice.
- tmllyd 12y agoYes, when discussing Pono it's important to differentiate between Pono the device and Pono the push towards higher sampling rates. The former may very well be better than other mobile devices in important ways as you mentioned. The latter is not backed up by evidence, but perched precariously on a conflation of the sound of low bit rate lossy compression and RedBook CD (which while on the edge, is adequate for delivery as far as the current evidence shows), and the naive misconception that faster and faster sampling equals better sound. There are solid technical reasons why 192 kHz sampling is too fast [1], even ignoring the evidence that shows that we don't benefit from the additional bandwidth (note the difference between modulator speed and sample rate!). There are scenarios when up-sampling an already digitised signal before certain kinds of processing is very beneficial (to reduce aliasing in the audible range), but that's an entirely separate discussion. [1] http://lavryengineering.com/pdfs/lavry-sampling-theory.pdf http://lavryengineering.com/pdfs/lavry-sampling-theory.pdf
- stolio 12y agoAlso, consumer headphones in this day and age will be designed specifically around hiding the deficiencies of a phone/music player because that's their most common use case. And they absolutely should be, people want their headphones to sound good. But headphones that make a bad source sound good may not be able to accurately portray what comes through a better player. I don't know if Pono is it but I think there's absolutely space for a hi-fi music player. Apparently Pono uses high quality DAC's: the ES9018 chip which cost about $65 to just go order.[0] The iPhone 6's chip costs ~$16.[1] That, plus the fact that the Pono uses better quality electronics throughout means there's good reason it should sound better. Ironically the 192k sampling rate is one of the least impressive parts of the player, to me. [0] - http://ecommerce.ismosys.com/ordering/product_info.php?manufacturers_id=34&products_id=479 http://ecommerce.ismosys.com/ordering/product_info.php?manuf... [1] - http://www.aliexpress.com/item/100-Original-New-for-iPhone-6-6-Plus-Cirrus-Logic-338S1201-Audio-Codec-IC-chip/32261899282.html http://www.aliexpress.com/item/100-Original-New-for-iPhone-6...