3 ms·
> But here’s the catch: According to people who study human physiology, 44.1-kHz recordings provide enough upper-end treble to exceed the capabilities of our ea
by tzs 12y ago
> But here’s the catch: According to people who study human physiology, 44.1-kHz recordings provide enough upper-end treble to exceed the capabilities of our ears. Anything higher and you’re spending money for sounds your dog can listen to but you can’t.
You can't hear above 20 kHz in the sense that if someone plays a 22 kHz tone and asks if you hear a tone, you won't be able to answer correctly more accurately than if you just guessed.
However, that doesn't mean that it makes no difference if music above 20 kHz is present.
See the paper "Inaudible high-frequency sounds affect brain activity: Hypersonic effect" [1], available for free online here [2].
They exposed listeners to gamelan music, which is rich in content above 22 KHz, sometimes with the ultrasonic sound included, sometimes with it removed, and looked at brain responses via EEG and PET. They clearly found statistical differences in brain response when the ultrasonic components were included.
They also did long double blind listening tests where the participants were asked to subjectively rate the sound, and the music that included the ultrasonics was rated higher.
[1] T. Oohashi, E. Nishina, M. Honda, Y. Yonekura, Y. Fuwamoto, N. Kawai, T. Maekawa, S. Nakamura, H. Fukuyama, and H. Shibasaki. Inaudible high-frequency sounds affect brain activity: Hypersonic effect. Journal of Neurophysiology, 83(6):3548–3558, 2000
[2] http://jn.physiology.org/content/83/6/3548.full http://jn.physiology.org/content/83/6/3548.full
- tmllyd 12y agoFlawed methodology and their results have since failed to be reproduced [1]. There's a run-down of the major issues with it in post #156 here [2] (all verifiable by reading the research paper). There are also various studies which essentially show the opposite results ([3], [4]). [1] http://www.aes.org/e-lib/browse.cfm?elib=12375 http://www.aes.org/e-lib/browse.cfm?elib=12375 [2] http://www.head-fi.org/t/266217/from-cd-to-sacd-how-much-of-difference/150 http://www.head-fi.org/t/266217/from-cd-to-sacd-how-much-of-... [3] http://www.aes.org/e-lib/browse.cfm?elib=14195 http://www.aes.org/e-lib/browse.cfm?elib=14195 [4] http://www.aes.org/e-lib/browse.cfm?elib=13185 http://www.aes.org/e-lib/browse.cfm?elib=13185
- tzs 12y agoThe run-down in post #156 at link is not very impressive. His first criticism is that the listeners knew the test was ABBA, with the listeners knowing that A and B are different. He thinks that is a flaw. It would be if the test were "can listeners tell the difference between A and B?". It's not when the test is "do listeners prefer A or B?". His second criticism is that there are slight differences in the spectra below 20 KHz. That's a legitimate criticism. Third, fourth, and fifth are ad hominem and similar bogus arguments. The sixth criticism is that if people do find they like the music with the high frequency components better it is because it is leading to more alpha waves and a relaxed state, which makes the people think they like the music more. He says that this isn't hearing and concludes that this somehow makes it irrelevant. This is ridiculous because it doesn't matter HOW it affects perception. If high frequencies somehow induce relaxation which makes us perceive the music more positively, presumably that would happen during a live concert. Hence, if we want the recorded music to be perceived as being as good as the live, we'd need those frequencies.