3 ms·
>and are therefore lower on the epistemological totem pole. Again, that is a philosophical position (logical positivism, basically) that would have to be justi
by foldr 12y ago
>and are therefore lower on the epistemological totem pole.
Again, that is a philosophical position (logical positivism, basically) that would have to be justified by philosophical argument. It's actually a position that's very difficult to justify, as we found out in the first half of the 20th century.
>"The claim that physics plays that special role within scientology is itself a scientological claim. If you want to justify it you'll have to study Dianetics and get audited by Tom Cruise!"
Surely if you wanted to show that physics played a special role within scientology, then you would indeed have to study scientology. I feel like you didn't even bother to read through that example after you'd constructed it.
In any case, your weird example does nothing to demonstrate any circularity in my original claim. The point is simply that if you take a philosophical position -- as you have on the epistemological role of physics -- then you have to justify it. I don't know of any way of justifying philosophical positions without making philosophical arguments. If you think that you have one, then let's see it.
> no less an eminence than John Wheeler is on video saying, "Philosophy is too important to be left to the philosophers."
Who should be doing philosophy is a separate question. Wheeler, as you note, agrees that philosophy is very important.