5 ms·
Meta question, but why is pitch events located in bars? It is a place associated with dating, mixed with free booze, and apparently used as a place for professi
by belorn 12y ago
Meta question, but why is pitch events located in bars? It is a place associated with dating, mixed with free booze, and apparently used as a place for professionalism and critical business decisions?
- zephod 12y agoI think that's just a question, as a meta-question would be a question about somebody else's question(?)
- tptacek 12y agoProfessionals can go to an event in a bar (and, yes, even consume a drink in a bar) without sexually harassing people. The problem here isn't the environment. The problem is the culture.
- tomp 12y agoThe problem here isn't the culture. The problem is the individuals.
- pc86 12y agoIt is absolutely the individuals, but it's also the culture that allows someone to write a blog post saying "this investor assaulted me while dangling $50k in front of me" and a sizable minority of the comments are some variation of "there is probably another side of the story" or "she didn't do enough [before|after]." Edit: To clarify, I agree there might be another side to this but until/unless the person the post's author is referring to makes a statement there is almost nothing to be gained by dismissing the author's account as some sort of half truth.
- tomp 12y agoWould you rather have a culture of 100% agreement? There are many different reasons why someone would write something like that in bad faith (mental illness, attention-seeking, etc.), it might be worth exploring such aspects (some stories fall apart under scrutiny, e.g. the UVA rape case). Also, I see nothing wrong with saying "she should loudly say 'did you just touch my boob?'", I think it would be beneficial if jerks were called out on shitty behavior more often.
- tptacek 12y agoWould you rather have a culture of 100% agreement? About some things? Yes. A culture of 100% agreement about people of European descent not being superior to other races, for instance, is a good thing. There is such a thing as an unproductive disagreement, and even of toxic disagreements. An attempt to disagree about the role of Jewish people in international banking conspiracies, for instance, would be unwelcome.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoWhat happens if these ideas are actually correct? Is it your desire for us to never learn certain truths? It's interesting that you openly acknowledge this, as well as what I now realize was support for shaming people who ask naughty questions (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9057857 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9057857). Most folks refuse to openly admit to this sort of anti-intellectualism, I'm glad to see it out in the open.
- pen2l 12y agoyummyfajitas, I just wanted to chime in and say that even though historically I've disagreed with you on most issues, I have actually as of late begun to appreciate your vehement defense of your viewpoints (which more often than not go against the HN herd mentality). You make exchanges on HN fun and mentally interesting. Please keep doing what you're doing.
- aaren 12y agoPersonally I find his exchanges tedious and draining, but to each their own.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoThanks for your (public) support. Most people write such things to me privately, since they don't want the downvotes.
- rmxt 12y ago
- belorn 12y agoThere will always be people who commit crimes. However, people under the influence tend to do act slightly less professional than others, and as such, professional work place tend to have a ban against it. Drinking on the job is the firing offense in most place, and for a good reason. A few conferences ago, I walk passed a drunk woman who turned around and hit me out of the blue. I could attribute that to conference culture, or I could attribute this to a woman who was so drunk she could barely stand and was talking to herself. If this had been at the work place, I would react very different, as in this case I just continued walking. Bars and free alcohol is not something I associate with a place of professionalism. I am not sure why so many people try to combine the two, which is why I ask.
- maemilius 12y agoThere's a marked difference between "drinking" and "being drunk". It's perfectly acceptable where I work to "have a beer", but I would fully expect to be, at least, reprimanded for anything more than that. EDIT: It's a context thing. If I was in the middle of a difficult problem and wanted a little "mental lubricant", I don't think anyone would question it. Drinking for no reason, or when being even slightly tipsy could affect performance, makes for perfect grounds for punishment. I understand the professionalism argument, but we're all adults here. If having a drink completely obliterates your sensitivities, you didn't have very many in the first place.
- cperciva 12y agoI think you're misunderstanding a broad question due to the narrow context of the article. The question here wasn't about whether people can drink without harassing people; the question was about whether the presence of alcohol is ideal for events which require professionalism and critical business decisions.
- tptacek 12y agoThis to me is analogous to those gender norm conversations in which people suggest that the problem is that tech is too competitive and aggressive, and that to be amenable to gender equality tech needs to tone itself down and become more collegial and cooperative. Which, when you think about it, is just a backhanded way of disqualifying women.
- cperciva 12y agoI'm not sure I understand what you're saying. Leaving sexism out of the picture entirely, do you think people consuming alcohol is conducive to making good business decisions? Because I certainly don't.
- tptacek 12y agoI think adults routinely navigate this situation without melting down, and so am very wary about attributing the author's experience in any way to alcohol. If you choose to consume alcohol in a business setting, you remain entirely responsible for your behavior.
- cperciva 12y agoI'm not sure how to make this any clearer: The question on this subthread has nothing to do with the article except for the location.
- tptacek 12y agoI know you think it doesn't, but I think you're wrong. I think this "business shouldn't happen in bars" talk is used by people to disqualify others. "Forget about fixing sexual harassment. Fix business happening in bars, first."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]