3 ms·
It always strikes me how things that other companies obsess over and create entire vocabularies for (we don't sell products, we sell experiences!) and experimen
by simonh 12y ago
It always strikes me how things that other companies obsess over and create entire vocabularies for (we don't sell products, we sell experiences!) and experiment with obsessively come so naturaly to Apple. Other companies produce hundreds of tweaked and targetted models of things in dozens of colours and patterns that are produced by different market oriented product groups and focus-tested to death.
Apple makes two products in the same category and they're both white, and they're white not because marketing, esperiences, focus groups or demographics but becuase Johny thinks it feels right for new things to be that way. Every 3-5 years or so they produce them in 5 different vivid primary colours, just for fun.
Conversely Apple absolutely obsesses at the executive level over and exhaustively iterates on seemingly trivial details like optimising the exact minimum necessary number of buttons in a UI screen, the precision and fluidity of a scrolling action and bounce animation, even just exactly the correct shade of yellow in an icon (real example). Things most companies would assign to a random intern and then forget about.
- notsony 12y ago> exhaustively iterates on seemingly trivial details like optimising the exact minimum necessary number of buttons in a UI screen, the precision and fluidity... This is a myth. The iOS maps debacle is just one example.
- pinaceae 12y agogot Forstall fired. pretty significant. other companies move those people to some X labs futuristic research dead ends.
- Kurtz79 12y agoIf I'm not mistaken the "debacle" had to do much more with the underlying data rather than the actual UI or design of the application. And it might be just one example, but for some reason when speaking of "Apple f..k ups" it's often the only one that comes up in discussions (at least in recent times)... I would say that it's a pretty impressive record.
- calinet6 12y agoAnecdotes aside, from a design standpoint, they tend to be significantly more successful than their competitors. There is a maximum to the level of quality that can be achieved in a given amount of time. For your particular example, look at the outcome: Apple Maps is now arguably on par with the Google data set and has several unique refinements. It's a much more successful product than when it was released.
- sah2ed 12y agoNo it is not. Even Steve Jobs obsessed over such details while he was Apple CEO like the shade of yellow in an icon mentioned by parent[1]. [1] Icon Ambulance: https://plus.google.com/+VicGundotra/posts/gcSStkKxXTw https://plus.google.com/+VicGundotra/posts/gcSStkKxXTw
- calinet6 12y agoIn a naïve sense, there is a bit of Zen philosophy in it. As you say, other companies obsess and work extremely hard to design products that are ultimately worse; what of the paradox that extreme effort results in a poor result? Why, that's one of the tenets of Zen. At the same time, while reducing certain parts to a paradoxical simplicity, Apple knows where the effort should be directed: at building systems. Getting to the root of problems and optimizing them away. Asking the question, what is the core from which all of this grows? What is its form? And working diligently on that, trusting that the output will be pure because of it. That's how quality is done; it's why the Japanese so readily accepted the teachings of W. Edwards Deming, and it's fundamentally how Jobs turned Apple around. Lots of lessons here, the most important of which are not technological in the slightest. Recommended reading: Zen in the Art of Archery: http://rum1.aarch.dk/uploads/media/Eugen_Herrigel-Zen_in_the_Art_of_Archery_01.pdf http://rum1.aarch.dk/uploads/media/Eugen_Herrigel-Zen_in_the... The Zen of Steve Jobs: http://www.forbes.com/special-report/2012/the-zen-of-steve-jobs.html http://www.forbes.com/special-report/2012/the-zen-of-steve-j... A Short intro to the teachings of W. Edwards Deming: https://shrikale.wordpress.com/2012/04/28/a-short-introduction-to-the-philosophy-of-w-edwards-deming/ https://shrikale.wordpress.com/2012/04/28/a-short-introducti... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Edwards_Deming http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Edwards_Deming
- jballanc 12y agoMost modern "business practices" are little more than hedges. Things like focus groups, market fit, etc. are not recipes to build amazing products, but rather ways to avoid making really bad products. It's not that being authentic is hard, but being authentic and profitable is. So we end up with a plethora of artificial-feeling mediocre-yet-profitable product companies, with the rare, exceptional, truly authentic company.
- saisi 12y ago'Things like focus groups, market fit, etc. are not recipes to build amazing products, but rather ways to avoid making really bad product' Never thought of it that way. I like this