2 ms·
> You can't control the internet However you can control how the internet gets into your country, and you can control the ISPs which distribute the internet wi
by falcolas 12y ago
> You can't control the internet
However you can control how the internet gets into your country, and you can control the ISPs which distribute the internet within your country, and you can control the businesses which use the internet in your country.
It's a difference without distinction, particularly since there are lots of companies and big thinkers who are dedicated towards helping others control the internet.
We (proponents of an open web) are fighting a losing battle; we're postponing the inevitable. Our generation will not be the dominant power in government for another generation or two, and those who are interested in a career in politics are too busy sanitizing their footprints to have strong opinions about the value of having an open internet.
We have been able to avoid the elephant for quite some time, but it's stomping across our playground now, and the scars of that stomping will affect our use of (and behavior on) that playground for the rest of its existence.
- jacquesm 12y agoIf the internet becomes disconnected islands of countries separated by 'great firewalls' it will simply cease to be the internet and something else that is harder to control and censor will take its place. The economic impact of that is such that I don't think it stands a chance of becoming a reality.
- falcolas 12y ago> something else that is harder to control and censor will take its place I'd be curious what you envision such a thing to be, that doesn't rely on the infrastructure and tacit support of governments to exist.
- wongarsu 12y agoWireless mesh networks operated with regular wifi routers are already popular in some cities. 5GHz WiFi can supposedly bridge 50km with the right antenna, which enables low-cost connections between cities and over borders. If the entire infrastructure was decentralized this way it would be near impossible to censor or control.
- falcolas 12y agoWireless mesh may indeed be the future, but scaling mesh networks beyond a few hundred nodes requires a lot of coordinated work, and there has to be quite a bit of work done in the routing protocols before it can be made to work properly. As for censoring a mesh network, there are many methods to do this, such as prohibiting the use of the frequencies with more than a certain amount of power (thus limiting the reach of any given network). Or the disruption of a few key nodes. Or a malicious actor participating in the network in order to disrupt communications. Or, perhaps the simplest method of all, adding enough noise by way of simple jammers to make reliable, fast communication impossible. The Government regulates the use of the RF bands; they do this at our behest because radio frequencies are a finite resource. To use Ham radio as an example - which has access to the frequencies a citizen can use to reach the furthest - they must operate within the restrictions outlined by the FCC within the US (and their counterparts in other countries). Specific to the problem of using RF as a replacement for the internet: ham radio operators can not do anything commercially, nor can they use encryption for which the key is not readily available. This necessarily limits what can be done to build out a long distance communications network without the government's tacit approval.