3 ms·
Despite, or maybe because of, the several thousand nuclear weapons ready to be deployed at short notice we get this from Steven Pinker in his book 'The Better A
by TheSpiceIsLife 12y ago
Despite, or maybe because of, the several thousand nuclear weapons ready to be deployed at short notice we get this from Steven Pinker in his book 'The Better Angels of Our Nature':
• Zero is the number of times that nuclear weapons have been used in conflict. Five great powers possess them, and all of them have waged wars. Yet no nuclear device has been set off in anger. It’s not just that the great powers avoided the mutual suicide of an all-out nuclear war. They also avoided using the smaller, “tactical” nuclear weapons, many of them comparable to conventional explosives, on the battlefield or in the bombing of enemy facilities. And the United States refrained from using its nuclear arsenal in the late 1940s when it held a nuclear monopoly and did not have to worry about mutually assured destruction. I’ve been quantifying violence throughout this book using proportions. If one were to calculate the amount of destruction that nations have actually perpetrated as a proportion of how much they could perpetrate, given the destructive capacity available to them, the post-war decades would be many orders of magnitudes more peaceable than any time in history.
Amazing.
- jacquesm 12y ago> Zero is the number of times that nuclear weapons have been used in conflict. Two is the number of times that nuclear weapons have been used in conflict.
- davidw 12y agoIf we concede that the guy is not completely ignorant of world history, he must be referring to something else, although admittedly it's not clear from the cited passage.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoPinker is making the distinction that the two cases you refer to weren't used in conflict, as such. They were used against civilian targets, not on the battlefield.
- jacquesm 12y agoAlmost all nukes are targeted at civilians. WW II not a conflict?
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoI like to believe that almost all nukes aren't actively targeting anything, but I guess all my knowledge comes from documentaries and the like, so I'm not really sure. I'll concede that, probably, almost all nukes, if they were to be used, would target civilians, I just take issue with the use of "are" in your statement. My understanding of the sequence of events was that WWII had already ended when the US dropped those two bombs, although the conflict with Japan continued in the Pacific theatre. It seemed to make a whole lot more sense when I read that paragraph in the context of the book, so I'll concede that Pinker's definition of 'zero nukes used in conflict' is debatable.
- jacquesm 12y agoHave a read: http://www.nrdc.org/nuclear/nwarplan.asp http://www.nrdc.org/nuclear/nwarplan.asp (2001) There is some logic to this, if you want to have the ability to do a retaliatory strike then you need to have your targets selected beforehand and in that case you might as well program that target into the missile ahead of time to save some time. If you live in a big city in Russia, Western Europe, China, North America or Australia there is likely a warhead with your number on it sitting around somewhere.
- wlievens 12y agoI'm pretty sure it was in the scope of a rather big conflict.
- pjc50 12y agoThis was the second world war, that distinction wasn't really maintained for air bombing. Use of incendiaries against cities was already widespread, and the firebombing of Tokyo killed more people than either of the two nuclear bombings.
- pelario 12y agoAlso > If one were to calculate the amount of destruction that nations have actually perpetrated as a proportion of how much they could perpetrate [...] is an extremely ridiculous metric!
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoIndeed, and I the way I read it in the context of the chapter, and the book, it was intended to come across as ridiculous. The infographic emphasises Pinker's point: The world has actually got a whole lot less violent over the past few decades, despite our ability to cause a lot more death and destruction, we choose not to. Another quote from Pinker, in the same book: "Also distorting our sense of danger is our moral psychology. No one has ever recruited activists to a cause by announcing that things are getting better, and bearers of good news are often advised to keep their mouths shut lest they lull people into complacency. Also, a large swath of our intellectual culture is loath to admit that there could be anything good about civilization, modernity, and Western society."
- millstone 12y agoHere is the preceding paragraph to give some context: I have spent a lot of this chapter on the statistics of war. But now we are ready for the most interesting statistic since 1945: zero. Zero is the number that applies to an astonishing collection of categories of war during the two-thirds of a century that has elapsed since the end of the deadliest war of all time. I’ll begin with the most momentous... So the "zero" figure means "since 1945."
- ekianjo 12y agoIndeed, but where they have been used, conventional incendiary bombs had done way, way more destruction than these two nukes. This being said, I'm not downplaying the horror of nukes, but there's certainly no need for nukes to massively kill people. WW2 is a good example of that.
- 7952 12y agoIt is interesting that you mention the US in the 1940s. After the war the allies were baldy outnumbered in Europe in terms of conventional force. Nukes were the only way that we could possibly defend against a Soviet attack. Nowadays nukes are seen as a detterant against other nukes; a much more distant threat that becomes less plausible. As that happens I wonder if the detterant effect of nukes on conventional forces is becoming diminshed. For nukes to be a detterant adverseries need to believe that we would use them. Otherwise it is the same old sabre ratteling leading to inevitable conflict.