4 ms·
> Pakistan/India is the most worrisome combination in that graph. why, you chose to include 'India' is kind of interesting. may you please elaborate ? afaik,
by signa11 12y ago
> Pakistan/India is the most worrisome combination in that graph.
why, you chose to include 'India' is kind of interesting. may you please elaborate ?
afaik, India (and China) are, still, following the NFU (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_first_use http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_first_use) policy.
- jacquesm 12y agoBecause they've been in a low level war for a long time. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashmir_conflict http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashmir_conflict
- muyuu 12y agoThis war has most likely stayed low level because both countries are aware of their nuclear capability. Probably not the happiest of developments but an all-out war is unlikely between nuclear powers.
- frandroid 12y agoExcept that India and Pakistan did have a low-intensity war _right after_ their reciprocal nuclear tests in 1998. Also, India has whooped Pakistan's ass every time they have been at war, both before and after nuclear weapons, so Pakistan has a much smaller incentive to trigger an all-out war. India isn't interested in capturing Pakistan and tilt its own demographic balance.
- muyuu 12y agoNothing of that contradicts the premise of what I said. Neither India or Pakistan would jeopardise the very existence of the other nation, because rather than just lie down and die they'd get a farewell message from the other side.
- latch 12y agoI assume he's including it because of its relation with Pakistan. For whatever reason Pakistan is a concern, India will remain a concern for its willingness to retaliate. (Note, I'm not saying they'd be wrong or right to retaliate, I'm simply sharing your parent's point of view that it's a worrisome combination).
- Tarang 12y agoJust something to keep in mind NFU's are just pledges. Russia, just out of the Soviet union had the pledge only to drop it. If you look at the countries that have the pledge its none of the earlier adopters (Nato or former Soviet states). This is important because it signifies that the pledge is more of a political statement to provide comfort to existing nuclear states at the time the pledge was made. India similarly changed its pledge to only apply against nuclear states more recently.
- nl 12y agoI'm not sure who fired first matters too much when you are on the receiving end. This is a serious point: the most serious "near misses" during the cold war were mostly caused by errors in early warning systems or procedures. Given the instability of Pakistan there is a non-zero chance that a non-government-authorised launch could occur. What would India's response be to that?