6 ms·
Author here: to run a house for a week, one of Tesla's battery would not be enough; you would need a few. I guess I wasn't much clear on the post.
by simonebrunozzi 12y ago
Author here: to run a house for a week, one of Tesla's battery would not be enough; you would need a few. I guess I wasn't much clear on the post.
- bsder 12y agoYou don't need to run the house for a week for a battery to be useful. The standard idea for this is for the houseowner to charge the battery during off-peak night hours and deplete it during peak hours thus helping the electric company to decrease the variation between peak and average load. This also has the effect of decreasing the amount of copper in a cable required to connect a house to the grid. If enough people have batteries, it also helps grid reliability. Most grid failures are single point of failure so having a distributed source allows power to keep flowing while repair is being carried out. There are a lot of advantages to having a big battery which could power a household for even a day.
- dikaiosune 12y agoIn the short-term, this also allows homeowners to take advantage of variable-rate billing from power companies. Charging a bank of batteries in off-peak would be much cheaper than getting full current during the peak. One problem is that eventually the cost savings is eroded by everyone jumping on the bandwagon to use the off-peak hours, which eventually become more expensive. Also, regarding your point about grid stability, if enough power consumers use these kinds of batteries, some sort of scheduling might be necessary to actually level out the grid's demand across all 24 hours.
- eyesee 12y agoAverage household consumption is around 30-ish kWh / day, so an 85 kWh Tesla battery would give you almost 3 days. The question I have is why you would need to store more than a day's energy for your home, assuming you charge it with solar? I suspect you need much less than this, and a 10-20 kWh home battery would be just fine to do the job.
- aetherson 12y agoRain?
- ddingus 12y agoRain is going to lower the solar output, but a properly sized installation will marginalize that. If a person is going to make the "off grid" investment, managing a balance between the solar and battery investments is going to be necessary. Batteries have cycle time and capacity limits, and their cost is high, but slowly improving. One probably should not assume a battery core will last 20 years, though some likely can. The solar installation probably will go 20 years, and solar can deliver savings in both the generation of electricity, as well as light and heat. A properly sized installation is going to be designed to work, in lower grade weather conditions, and after it's lost some of it's efficiency, for a very long time. Of the two, it makes the most sense to be lean on the battery investment. New tech, cost reductions, etc... will likely play out a few times during the life of the solar installation. And that installation can be added to / upgraded somewhat more incrementally without having to give up earlier investments in many cases. The battery, unless it is very modular, won't share these same advantages to the same degree. And the house can be improved as well. Smart devices to manage power use, like the Nest thermostat, can be upgraded or trained, or just will deliver battery aware use profiles. People can adapt a little. Just choosing to wear some clothes in the winter rather than maintain that comfort zone heat level saves quite a bit. LED lighting, thermal assist for warm water, use of more energy efficient materials, and the list goes on and on... A couple lifestyle changes could very well see that battery last longer than expected.
- simonebrunozzi 12y agoThat was Jason's assumption, not mine. :)
- ChuckMcM 12y agoOn my particular solar installation its production is lower in the winter than the summer (combination of temperature and Sun angle) 3 days would be fine for 99.9% of the year I expect and I would hardly ever draw from the grid.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoHi Simone, when I installed the solar system on my house (5.2kW, 2001) we seriously looked at going "off grid" (which means batteries). The problem at the time was that getting a few 10's of kWh of batteries was both quite expensive (you basically either built your own system or used an over priced data center UPS type system) and quite intense in its maintenance. Tesla is working both the reliability and the maintenance issues simultaneously. That means that using their tech, with two of their battery packs (so that I can disconnect one for service/replacement while the other can run my house) would very much be an interesting "feature" for Solar City to offer. Typical peak power requirements of a house might hit 25kW but a car it can easily hit over 75kW (100 hp equivalent). So they have the inverter technology to build a whole house inverter. The bottom line is they have built for a car, that which could be sold for houses, with the "hard bits" mostly solved. But that only becomes a useful thing if they excess battery capacity because I'm sure they can make far more money selling this tech wrapped up in a car than they can as a 'get your house off the grid' kit.
- simonebrunozzi 12y agoHi Chuck, that's a good point - but I guess we're still a few years away from cheap enough batteries. :)
- frankus 12y agoDepends on the house, but for the average Tesla owner I suspect you're right. 85 kWh would last me over half a month (I live in a smallish house with big windows, no A/C, LED lighting, and gas for heating/cooking/hot water)