9 ms·
Many of the people arguing that quantum physics undermines logic are physicists who understand QM as well as anyone. For example, Lawrence Krauss often suggests
by foldr 12y ago
Many of the people arguing that quantum physics undermines logic are physicists who understand QM as well as anyone. For example, Lawrence Krauss often suggests that theistic arguments based on classical logic are undermined by QM (which shows that reality isn't "logical").
The idea that QM is deeply weird, counterintuitive, challenging, profound, etc., is one that's relentlessly pumped out by the physics PR machine. In other words, physicists are fine with physicists making wild philosophical speculations about QM; they just don't want anyone else to join the party. Well, it doesn't work like that. Either this stuff has philosophical implications or it doesn't. And if it does, those are fair game for philosophers to comment on. (And sure, some of these philosophers don't always know as much about the physics as they should, but their ignorance in this respect is usually nothing in comparison to modern physicists' ignorance of philosophy.)
- sumitviii 12y agoWhen have physicists commented on philosophical ideas?
- foldr 12y agoMany of the great physicists of the first half of the 20th century did. There was a lot of interchange between logical positivism (the Vienna Circle etc.) and physics.
- VLM 12y agoWhen a physicist speculates, and someone points out that implies a sign reversal in ohms law, "oh well, I'll try again later". There's an immense collection of constraints based on experimental results that they try to respect. When a philosopher speculates, and someone points out a problem with the theory, welcome to the wonderful world of sophistry and logical fallacy, would you like your ad hominem attack flame merely well done or extra crispy? Usually with a trendy side dish of political correctness and authoritarianism. Not to mention the typical attitude of "experimental results, who needs em?"
- foldr 12y ago>When a physicist speculates..there's an immense collection of constraints based on experimental results that they try to respect. No, not really. See e.g. Krauss's speculations that I mentioned above. What you say about philosophy is just a caricature. At least point to specific philosophers or specific articles.
- nevinera 12y agoOf course it has philosophical implications. The problem is that philosophers largely don't understand QM well enough to talk about them. To be fair, many physicists don't either.
- foldr 12y agoCould you give a specific example of such a philosopher? Or some kind of justification of the "largely"? How carefully have you examined that body of work?
- nevinera 12y ago>How carefully have you examined that body of work? Don't be ridiculous. Very few professors of philosophy would have even had enough math to read the basic expressions necessary for such understanding. I don't need to survey the literature to be confident that the significant majority of philosophers don't understand quantum mechanics, cannot explain the chemical or electrical mechanisms by which brains work, and don't understand statistics well enough to interpret experimental data. Those things require a deal of training and experience that a philosophy education is not likely to provide. There are plenty of philosophers out there that do understand any or all of those things, obviously. Did you think I was trying to claim that there are none?
- foldr 12y agoHave you read any bad papers about quantum mechanics by philosophers? You're playing the hard-headed empiricist here, so don't just speculate -- show us the data. The philosophers who write about physics usually have some training in it besides their philosophy education.
- stolio 12y ago> (And sure, some of these philosophers don't always know as much about the physics as they should, but their ignorance in this respect is usually nothing in comparison to modern physicists' ignorance of philosophy.) I realize you're just debate-baiting, but this isn't anywhere near a symmetric situation. For the philosopher physics is a bridge to reality, it's a source of invaluable information. I've seen no evidence philosophy has anything to offer the physicist that's of equal importance.
- foldr 12y ago>For the philosopher physics is a bridge to reality, The claim that physics plays that special role within philosophy is itself a philosophical claim. If you want to justify it you'll have to study some philosophy! More generally, your attitude is one that's typical of physicists these days, who tend to approach the philosophical literature with a huge superiority complex. That's not an attitude that was shared by the 20th century's greatest physicists.
- avn2109 12y agoI appreciate your point about the historical precedent of interdisciplinary respectfulness by great physicists. However, it's worth noting that this respectfulness was far from unanimous. For example, no less an eminence than John Wheeler is on video saying, "Philosophy is too important to be left to the philosophers." [0] Also, physics _is_ special, and does "play a special role" in all topics pertaining to reality, because it is by definition falsifiable by experiment. Many disciplines (including but obviously not limited to philosophy) lack that falsifiability, and are therefore lower on the epistemological totem pole. In these sorts of debates, it's sometimes helpful to see if claims become ridiculous when you replace "philosophy" with some known-silly ideology. >>"The claim that physics plays that special role within scientology is itself a scientological claim. If you want to justify it you'll have to study Dianetics and get audited by Tom Cruise!" That sounds as ridiculous as it is, because it's broadly circular. And the core logic there doesn't get any better when we switch back to "philosophy." [0] http://www.aps.org/units/fhp/newsletters/fall2009/wheeler.cfm http://www.aps.org/units/fhp/newsletters/fall2009/wheeler.cf...