3 ms·
Yes, but it's hard to explain succinctly. TL;DR: the Afshar experiment does not actually show what it purports to show. It's a bit of rhetorical sleight-of-ha
by lisper 12y ago
Yes, but it's hard to explain succinctly. TL;DR: the Afshar experiment does not actually show what it purports to show. It's a bit of rhetorical sleight-of-hand. The reason is the presence of the lens, which supposedly creates an image of the two slits, but in fact does not. What it really does (which can be demonstrated mathematically) is create an interference pattern that looks like an image of the two slits but really isn't. So it is not the case that because it looks like a photon went through one slit or the other at the end of the experiment that it did in fact go through one slit or the other.
If you're interested in the details, Feynman has a good explanation in "QED: The strange theory of light and matter" using a mirror rather than a lens but amounting to the same thing.