4 ms·
You can skip most of this but the bit about the Afshar experiment looks important. According to Wikipedia it's still controversial. Does anyone know more about
by skybrian 12y ago
You can skip most of this but the bit about the Afshar experiment looks important. According to Wikipedia it's still controversial. Does anyone know more about it?
- lisper 12y agoYes, but it's hard to explain succinctly. TL;DR: the Afshar experiment does not actually show what it purports to show. It's a bit of rhetorical sleight-of-hand. The reason is the presence of the lens, which supposedly creates an image of the two slits, but in fact does not. What it really does (which can be demonstrated mathematically) is create an interference pattern that looks like an image of the two slits but really isn't. So it is not the case that because it looks like a photon went through one slit or the other at the end of the experiment that it did in fact go through one slit or the other. If you're interested in the details, Feynman has a good explanation in "QED: The strange theory of light and matter" using a mirror rather than a lens but amounting to the same thing.
- VLM 12y agoIts a redefinition game. Notice how vital it is for proponents to describe the path of an (admittedly very fast) bit of light as "at the same time" when it obviously is not. By analogy, my coworker and I superficially drove home "at the same time" starting and stopping in about the same place, but it would be highly misguided to say we actually were coincident at any given instant, the commute was instantaneous, in some metaphysical sense we are the same we just look different sometimes, or there are not two coworkers but an infinity of coworkers in a multiverse commute. (edited to add, I'm not implying a hidden variable analogy which is obviously not how the real world works, more of a GIGO data analysis leads to weird conclusions analogy) Light can behave like a wave or a particle. Nothing can directly detect both ways at the same time. Its perfectly acceptable to pipe the output of a gadget that sees "waves" to the input of a tester that sees "particles". Unsurprisingly, light, not having any hidden variables, doesn't know its own history very well and will happily be detected however you'd like to test it. I think the author aims at the wrong target. The biggest problem with "quantum mystics" is TV grade technobabble and scam artists. Merely taking a fairy tale and saying its not fake anymore because "quantum" was sprinkled on it doesn't make it any less ridiculous. As we all here know, its like saying "security" is merely a checkbox, perhaps an include file setting, not something that has to be baked into the cake from the beginning.