7 ms·
Probably two things going on. 1. The "significant positions" are relative to the size of the company. Startup X's director of marketing /= Twitter's director o
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
Probably two things going on.
1. The "significant positions" are relative to the size of the company. Startup X's director of marketing /= Twitter's director of marketing. So the competence needs aren't the same and as a result the salary reflects that.
2.Funding levels aren't there to offer higher salaries.
There is no good answer to either of these.
I see stupid comments on here all the time like, "Well if you can't pay me 200k a year with unlimited vacation and healthcare and a 401k then you aren't ready for those positions." Fine, go work for Google and don't worry about startup jobs, that shouldn't prevent Startup X for trying to fill that position with those skills.
People also need a reality check. 110k is double the median salary for California [1], so if you are getting those offers anywhere else than SF you are making out like a bandit.
Their ownership is purely symbolic, in a relative sense, and it's a symbol of how little they own relative to a founder.
This is naiive. An employees risk is several magnitudes less than the founders across many factors. That said, some of the first employees get shafted on equity/pay and I think that is worth addressing, but again it is based on market rates. The other thing you can choose is to go work for a employee owned company if you choose.
[1]http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/07/16/156688596/what-americans-earn http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/07/16/156688596/what-ame...
- bayesianhorse 12y agoIf someone works for a start up at lower rates, and very little equity, then they also carry a lot of risk. The pay-difference amounts to an investment, whose profit entirely depends on the value of the equity, which is close to 0 in most cases.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoAgreed, which is why I stated as such. Determining equity/pay balance for employees is very difficult in the very early stages. This is why we lean towards the high side for pay vs equity because it is immediately tangible. I think it is largely dependent on the hire what this ratio should be and shouldn't be a formula - despite what "the industry" says. At the end of the day it's whatever the individuals think is fair.
- sjg007 12y agoThe biggest risk is not getting retirement started at all or matching 401k.
- bendmorris 12y ago>110k is double the median salary for California This is irrelevant to the discussion. Startups aren't hiring cashiers and fry cooks. Engineers make more than the median.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoRight, double seems totally reasonable for your median dev with a couple years experience.
- 300bps 12y agoRight, double seems totally reasonable for your median dev with a couple years experience. Well fortunately we don't have to decide salaries based on what a founder's self-serving definition of "totally reasonable" is. Instead, we have a well functioning market that finds efficient salaries. (That is, when large tech companies aren't colluding to artificially lower salaries through illegal no-poaching agreements).
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoWell fortunately we don't have to decide salaries based on what a founder's self-serving definition of "totally reasonable" is Except that's not the case. Those numbers are what the market is signaling and apparently the OP doesn't like it. That's my point. The OP is saying, the market isn't offering enough. I say, well apparently it is otherwise it would be higher. So it much be good enough for most people.
- 300bps 12y agoI think you might be making the classic mistake of thinking the market is equal to what people advertise on the Internet. As I've heard a million times on Pawn Stars, "Anyone can ask for anything on the Internet. What are they selling for?" I work in Delaware and $110k per year salary for software engineers would be an average salary for someone with some experience. According to a cost of living calculator, someone making $110k per year in Wilmington, DE would need to make $170k per year in San Francisco for the same standard of living.
- funkwyrm 12y ago"An employees risk is several magnitudes less than the founders across many factors. " I read often about founder risk, but I think it is overstated for non-bootstrapped companies. If you are a founder of a funded company, you get a salary the same as everyone else. In that case, what exactly is your "magnitudes greater" risk?
- AndrewKemendo 12y ago>If you are a founder of a funded company, you get a salary the same as everyone else. Depends on the stage from what I have seen. Most of the other founders I know, including myself, take 10-15% less salary than many of the employees. Also once funded, investors will expect founders will take a haircut for a while.
- mbesto 12y agoAgreed. Most founders I know (in SV) take $50-80k in the first 1-2 years.
- dean 12y ago10-15% less salary does not equal "several magnitudes" more risk. To my mind, for a funded company, the risk is the same for founders and employees. The worst that can happen for both is unemployment.
- rco8786 12y agoFirst, you're ignoring all the risk a founder has already taken just to get to a funded state. Second, many times(always?) a founder has personal savings wrapped up in the company. Third, an employee can always just quit and find a new job. The founder is much more tightly bound to his/her company because of obligations to investors, other employees, clients, etc. To say that "the worst case scenario" for both is unemployment is true, but you're ignoring many other factors that make it far more likely for the founder to be stuck going down with the ship while employee walks away Scott free.
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoNot that it's actually possible for most, but what happened to hiring the absolute best person? Because apparently they don't want to take lower salary and higher risk? I mean we try to hire the best person we can afford - full stop. That means as much as we could pay and as much equity as we can give. At the end of the say it's a market and they will find the pay/risk level they want.
- sulam 12y agoI often see people refer to employee/founder risk as a reason for for employee's getting less stock in the early days, but I think this is the wrong way to think about it. As an employee or a founder, your risk in working at a startup is very low. Both of you experience some degree of opportunity cost, but you're mostly "risking" the possibility of having to go work at a significantly higher base salary with more benefits, perks, and possibly the same expected value in terms of stock. So, what gives? The answer is that we don't pay people based on risk. Fire fighters truly have a high risk job, yet they typically earn less than many skilled white collar jobs. Rightly or wrongly, we pay people roughly according to their economic output, and probably not even their fully captured economic output (see: teachers). The reason people use this risk language when it comes to startups is because there's a place where there _is_ some economic risk being experienced, and these people talk about "de-risking" the business all the time: investors. Investors are risking capital, typically all of it, for the chance of an outsized return. As a company de-risks, meaning as it becomes more of an actual business vs a business model search engine, the return an investor might expect for their money is naturally reduced (from 100X to 10X to 2-3X over the course of funding a 'typical' SV startup). Founders often put capital into a business as well, in the form of maxed out credit cards, deferred salary, and sometimes actual bootstrap $$$. Their monetary contribution is typically quite a bit smaller than an investor's, though, so why do they get such a huge share of the ownership? Again, it comes down to economic value. A founder is producing a huge amount of economic value simply by taking an idea and turning it into a real thing that people can evaluate, invest in, work for, etc. An employee isn't creating nearly as much value, although I think it's pretty obvious that the first employee at a YC startup is probably creating more than %.01 of the value in the company so an offer like that isn't fair. I do find it fascinating that so much of the investment language of risk gets used when speaking about employees. I think some of this is just lazy thinking, but it's also partly psychological -- you want employees to feel like investors vs having them feel like contractors, for instance. And honestly, if a company gets really big, an employee with 1% stake in a company is still filthy rich, even if the guy he had beer with the whole way is now going to Davos on his private jet.
- pcthrowaway 12y agoI don't know about the bay area, but fire fighters can make over $80,000 a year in Portland, OR[1], which isn't so bad I agree with the point that we don't pay people based on the risk though, as I worked at arguably one of the most dangerous jobs in the U.S. (pizza delivery in a top-5 violent crime rate cities) for years, making far less than a fire fighter. [1]http://www.portlandoregon.gov/bhr/article/462925 http://www.portlandoregon.gov/bhr/article/462925
- RomanPushkin 12y ago> 110k is double the median salary for California Bay Area is not California. You can rent for less than $1K in Sacramento, and life is cheaper there. But generally you can't live in Sacramento and work in SF. TODO: find out the median salary for Bay Area
- mchannon 12y agoI've worked with at least two people who commuted in from out past Sacramento (1 from Elk Grove and 1 from Lincoln). They tended to remote when they could, but also stayed with family or motels in the near east bay certain weeknights. That also didn't include the people who flew into SFO every Monday morning from home 1000+ miles away. They always won the "how awful my commute was" game.