4 ms·
The government owns all the land and rents out 10 year leases to the highest bidder in the case of contention. So car company A leases some land for $x build
by michaelt 12y ago
The government owns all the land and rents out 10 year
leases to the highest bidder in the case of contention.
So car company A leases some land for $x builds a factory at a cost of $5x. Good news, jobs for the local economy and whatnot. The factory can't be moved, and they want to operate it for 30 years.
After 10 years the lease comes up for renewal. Car company A wants to renew the lease for another $x. But car company B wants to fuck with their competitors, so they put in a bid for $3x. They know they won't win so they won't have to pay (car company A don't want to lose their $5x factory so they'll have to outbid) - they just want to raise their competitors' expenses.
That happens a few times and all of a sudden nobody wants to build factories any more.
Then you realise the same thing applies to your asshole neighbour's house...
- walterbell 12y agoHow about a Dutch auction?
- michaelt 12y agoIt still doesn't solve the root problem that it's possible to increase land's value and we want to encourage people to do it. Land with a house on it is worth more than land without a house on it. Land that's been cleaned up is worth more than land that was contaminated in the past. If, a few years after you increase the land's value, all that extra value goes to the state, why should anyone increase land's value?
- tormeh 12y agoHow about the difference in rent from one term to the next is paid to the previous tenant? The goal, after all, is not to funnel money to the government, but to not award property rights squatting.
- tormeh 12y agoThat's a good one. I don't think these problems are insurmountable, though. With enough thought, edge cases can usually be fixed. Proposal: In the event that a financial loss is suffered by the previous tenant losing the lease, the successor must compensate the previous tenant in full. With enough of a time buffer between the auction and the transfer this might solve the problem. A Dutch auction, as mentioned in another comment, is an interesting modification as well.