8 ms·
How Likely Is It That Birth Control Could Let You Down?
- misiti3780 12y agoInteresting "article", nice visualizations - where did that data come from though ?
- reubenmorais 12y agoSources are listed after the article: > Sources: James Trussell, Office of Population Research, Princeton University; Brookings Institution
- raquo 12y agoThat's not saying much. The guy wrote hundreds of articles on this topic since 1972: http://www.princeton.edu/~trussell/publications.htm http://www.princeton.edu/~trussell/publications.htm The charts also ignore the fact that risk is more correlated with number of usages rather than number of years of usage, so the numbers themselves are quite useless. Overall, I am disappointed by this... um... style of journalism.
- reubenmorais 12y ago> The charts also ignore the fact that risk is more correlated with number of usages rather than number of years of usage, so the numbers themselves are quite useless. I don't know how you're expecting that to be measured/reported. They're just building on top of how effectiveness of contraceptive methods is already reported, which comes from polling actual people and extrapolating from that, not some theoretical calculation of the chance of failure per individual sexual relation.
- raquo 12y agoI'd say it's not unreasonable to expect a question of "how many times did you use said contraception last year" in the poll/questionnaire. If the "perfect" scenario can be self-reported, this is fair game as well I think.
- adsjfk 12y ago>How the numbers were calculated: The probability that a woman doesn't get pregnant at all over a given period of time is equal to the success rate of her contraceptive method, raised to the power of the number of years she uses that method. This does assume that the chance of getting pregnant after a year is independent of the person/people using it, though... presumably there are reasons other than a random roll of the dice why various birth control methods fail, which could well affect the distribution. (It also seems absolutely crazy to give these statistics "per year" when I'd feel pretty confident in saying that it depends on how often you have sex!)
- eurleif 12y agoWell, there are separate numbers for "perfect use" versus "typical use". Presumably, perfect use is independent of the person using it.
- adsjfk 12y agoExample: I'd guess that when hormonal birth control fails despite being used perfectly, it could well be related to the person's particular biology. So if it failed for them one year, there'd be a high chance of it failing the next. And if it worked for the previous year, there's a lower chance of whatever goes wrong going wrong. (I'd be curious to hear from someone who knows what they're talking about, though!)
- pstrateman 12y agoThe perfect use line for "Pill, Evra patch, NuvaRing" virtually matches that of "Hormonal implant" The key difference is the typical use lines are wildly different. (I thought it was interesting that Hormonal implant was more effective than male sterilization.)
- cperciva 12y agoPerfect use means "the user did not make any mistakes". A woman who gets pregnant after forgetting to take the pill one day is a "typical use" birth control failure; a woman who becomes pregnant because her natural hormone levels are such that the birth control pill (consistently taken at the same time every day) doesn't render her infertile is a "perfect use" birth control failure. Similarly, couples who intend to use condoms but occasionally forget (or get carried away etc.) would be "typical use", but a man with a cat-like barbed penis which makes holes in condoms could still qualify as "perfect use".
- daurnimator 12y agoI'm happy to read that a Hormonal implant is the most effective (even better than sterilization.... I didn't expect that). http://www.implanon-usa.com/en/consumer/index.xhtml http://www.implanon-usa.com/en/consumer/index.xhtml
- sejje 12y agoHappy for what reason? I've dated two women over a long period of time, part of the time with, and part of the time without, a hormonal implant. They both had drastic changes in mood, in my opinion for the worse, with the implant in. Depressed, unambitious. For one of them that was nearly the opposite of normal.
- stinos 12y agoI'm not surprised. The pill tends to have such effects, though sometimes very subtle, as well. For my wife it seriously reduced sex drive. Which we only figured out after she stopped taking it. Which in turn and in the spirit of the moment made us seriously question the whole anticonception-using-drugs thing: what is this scam? How did society let this ever happen? Millions of women paying huge amounts for something which basically makes them feel worse. Erm, what? Of course we also realized it's not as black and white like that, and it does prevent pregnancy. But still, something to think about.
- kaybe 12y agoDepends, for women with strong problems during period the pill can improve those a lot. Which might mean that instead of having to stay in bed with a hot water bottle and terrible pain for a day+ each month one only feels slightly uncomfortable.
- silencio 12y agoThat's a potential problem with most hormonal contraceptives, not just the implant. That's also not something that all women experience. I've never had a problem beyond minimal weight gain with anything I've ever used (multiple forms of pills, nuvaring, depo, mirena IUD) and same for many of my female friends are in my situation, while I have some that only stick with very specific brands/types, and some that swore off birth control altogether. I'm pretty happy that the implant is so effective for something so minimally invasive (in comparison to sterilization), personally, and I'll be considering it for my next form of birth control. I love what hormonal options do for me and I would never consider anything else.
- parennoob 12y agoThe male birth-control pill is the need of the hour, yesterday. These stats give me the chills.
- parennoob 12y ago[can't edit original comment for some reason, so follow up:] ...A safe, low side-effect, potentially reversible male birth-control pill would be a godsend for men who want to control their reproductive potential. I have heard that RISUG )(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversible_inhibition_of_sperm_under_guidance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversible_inhibition_of_sperm_...) has shown promise, so may be something to watch out for.
- michaelsbradley 12y agoFor couples looking for a non-surgical, non-pharmaceutical approach to family planning, the Billings and Sympto-Thermal methods of NFP are are good options: http://www.thebillingsovulationmethod.org/ http://www.thebillingsovulationmethod.org/ http://ccli.org/nfp/stm-method/ccl-stm-method.php http://ccli.org/nfp/stm-method/ccl-stm-method.php Both are well-researched (backed by solid science), easy to learn and use, and have effectiveness rates as good or better than many methods of artificial contraception. Also, they naturally help the couples become increasingly aware of their fertility, and can aid them in achieving pregnancy if/when that is desirable.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoThe charts in this article disagree with your "easy to learn" statement about fertility awareness methods. It is one of the least effective in typical use although theoretically it's not bad. As you say these methods are more useful for getting pregnant than for not.
- michaelsbradley 12y agoHere is the paper presented by Prof. S. Z. Qian in September 2000 regarding a large trial of the Billings Method conducted in China: http://www.lifeissues.net/writers/qia/qia_01nfpchina.html http://www.lifeissues.net/writers/qia/qia_01nfpchina.html "Due to its high efficacy, low expenditure and extreme safety incomparable by any other contraceptive methods, the BOM is well accepted by the Chinese couple of different cultural and economical backgrounds." So, while I do not have enough background information on the chart provided by NYT, it doesn't seem to square with other known data.
- silencio 12y agoI don't think it necessarily contradicts the NYT chart. Fertility awareness ~can~ be fairly effective. I think the problem is that the linked paper only studied women for 12 months (try doing NFP for 10 years and saying it's effective) and they cherrypicked them too... normal cycles (!), partnered, specific age range, para 1 (!!!). That is definitely not going to match up with what NYT used and I wouldn't be surprised if any one of those points ends up making a difference. I'm trying to get pregnant for the first time right now with still irregular cycles, and NFP for the purpose of pregnancy (educated, and I spend a LOT of time on a lot of communities about this) is a huge headache. There's no way I'd try this as birth control.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoIf spermicides are useless why are they allowed to market them?
- stinos 12y agoMight be a similar story to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8927403 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8927403, just for a different product. tldr; even if a drug's effect is questionable it can be put on the market or even recommended by official channels. As to the question why I can only guess, and my guess would be that money is the driving factor. Then again, I don't know anything at all about spermicides and whether they work (sometimes) or not so maybe someone with a better insight on the matter should comment on this.
- gleenn 12y agoThey aren't useless, for instance you can use them in addition to condoms to increase the effectiveness.
- xpda 12y ago5% of female sterilizations fail? That certainly doesn't sound right.
- silencio 12y agoThe 'tied tubes' type can fail because the tubes can grow back together. The implant type (causes scar tissue to form and block the tubes) can fail if the tubes are not fully blocked or something else happens to them.
- adrianhoward 12y agoSince I know of two people it failed on (one got pregnant, one caught it and had a second op) - it sounds right to me.
- llamataboot 12y agoIt amazes me that IUDs aren't more popular in the US, despite being widespread in Europe. There is generally some pain during the the procedure, and some heavier cramps during menstruation for a few months, but other than that it is a method with virtually zero side effects, zero ability to screw it up, and as good as it gets in terms of prevention. I know about 10 women in the US with IUDs (including my wife) and all of them recommend them with an evangelical fervor.
- silencio 12y agoI think it's the upfront cost, which is still a problem. The only reason I ever got my Mirena IUD was that it was the first month Obamacare kicked in for mandatory birth control coverage and my insurance covered it. Before then, I wasn't willing to entertain the idea of an $800+ option when I was doing okay with other things (mostly nuvaring). Mirena was by far one of the best forms of birth control I had ever used though :) There are definitely problems with the procedure and the IUDs themselves for plenty of women, too, let's not ignore that. But it is hard to screw up and it is a pretty easy method. I hope that better coverage leads to more IUDs and less unwanted pregnancies :)
- ChrisNorstrom 12y agoI thought there was a lawsuit on Mirena ? Due to side effects and perforations. http://www.drugwatch.com/mirena/ http://www.drugwatch.com/mirena/
- silencio 12y agoHonestly, that looks like some ambulance chaser site. All IUDs can perforate a uterus. Any form of birth control can cause side effects. Any medication can cause problems in general. Hell, pregnancy has side effects and can potentially cause death :P You just learn to know what to look for and you get it looked at, that's all. And your doctor can tell you if you're not a good candidate for a particular medication (i.e. smokers shouldn't use hormonal contraceptives), like you should be doing already.
- 12y ago
- cmdrfred 12y agoReally the ideal solution is to somehow make humans sterile by default with a pill that allows you to become fertile on demand.
- imjustsaying 12y agoWe can even push stage 1 of the product out (100% sterilization of everyone, everywhere) before we build stage 2 (the pill that reverses stage 1). At that point, even non-profits will be throwing investment money into the business.
- cmdrfred 12y agoYou could open source and crowdfund stage one and your close relationship to the project would give you the insight to develop stage two and patent it first. Overpopulation in a future with limitless labor isn't a non-issue. Charge maybe 20 grand a child? http://masseffect.wikia.com/wiki/Genophage http://masseffect.wikia.com/wiki/Genophage
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kaybe 12y agoThere are plants like that in the amazon - the indians give them to adolescents to make them infertile for about 5 years (might be a fungus because some other plants to start and end fertility looked the same to the author of the book I read, and the people she showed them). There are a lot of amazing medical plants (one that you put on a rotting tooth - and it just falls out like that), and sadly we don't have access to most of them.. professionals I discussed this with put it on a high chance of, uh, interesting side effects (also psychological) and the high costs of testing. It's sad, still, especially since we are losing the knowledge.
- calinet6 12y agoAnd our species proceeds to die off within two generations.
- andrewstuart2 12y agoUnexpected pregnancy is only a fraction of the problems that birth control brings. I've had way too many friends struggle for years to find the "right birth control for them" at a high personal cost. Unsurprisingly, trying to make your body think it's already pregnant via external hormones can have some significant side effects. I mean, I suppose decreased libido probably contributes to the effectiveness of a birth control method, but why bother? Or how about some frustrating weight gain from your body trying to nurture and protect a non-existent baby? Or maybe you prefer that sex become uncomfortable or painful? Even IUDs are only recommended if you're not thinking about ever having kids; the danger of infertility is still too high. "I don't want to wear condoms" is all-too-often the only reason that hormonal birth control is ever considered. It's my personal opinion that men are the ones that need to suck it up. Every time. Chances sex is less pleasurable for men? Probably 100%. But the chances that hormonal birth control will significantly diminish some woman's quality of life are statistically significant. The only way to avoid it is to go with condoms. Don't want kids? Don't want to take chances? Don't have sex. You think it's a coincidence that one of the most pleasurable experiences possible also happens to lead to the continuation of our species? Ha.
- davyjones 12y ago> Don't want kids? Don't want to take chances? Don't have sex. If you are done with predetermined quota, one can go under the knife and start shooting blanks at no bodily cost.
- Klinky 12y agoEven vasectomy is not perfect. There is risk involved with the procedure. You're likely going to get a lecture regardless of how many kids you've had, and if you've had zero be prepared for outright refusal by many doctors. There is also some stigma attached to it. Some women find a man who's had a vasectomy a turn off.
- cpursley 12y ago> Some women find a man who's had a vasectomy a turn off Of course, this is a mating game. The time to get a vasectomy is after having children in a relationship that you know is going to last.
- cryofan 12y agoLife ...uh...finds a Way