3 ms·
> If only we had known this before Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib. /s Somehow I suspect they didn't really want to get more info. They wanted to punish, and to ins
by rdtsc 12y ago
> If only we had known this before Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib. /s
Somehow I suspect they didn't really want to get more info. They wanted to punish, and to instill fear, mostly because deep down it felt good to them. Officially there was an excuse "War on terror". But it could have been done just as easily under another slogan, maybe "War on Drugs" or "War on Communism" and so on.
Going a back a step, I also believe there is a high number of psycopaths who rise to power in intelligence agencies. Even if you look at something silly like reliance on passing polygraphs, for entering and staying in the organization. Psycopaths would do much better there. After many iterations, shit like that rises to the top.
- leereeves 12y agoAfter 9/11, a lot of Americans wanted to see "the terrorists" suffer, but there may be something dangerous about a person who can bear to personally inflict the torture. Just having people in power who are willing to order torture worries me.
- afarrell 12y agoMore than being able to order thousands of men to storm a beach or an entire city of wood and paper to go up in a storm of fire? Being a head of a state has always required making decisions about using force in horrific ways. Torturing O(30) people is dwarfed by that.
- Spooky23 12y agoYou're assuming that information gathering is the primary purpose of the actions. Maintaining control or proviking a response are two other possibilities among others. Polygraph is a great example. It is clearly pseudoscience, but the fact that your employees know that they can be interrogated on a broad variety of topics at will guides their behavior.
- jqm 12y agoAgree that these techniques likely weren't intended to get more information. But maybe they were deliberate instigation rather than punishment or cruelty. Possibly designed to stir up outrage, continued resistance and counterattacks? That way, the occupiers would manifestly need to keep a presence in the region... you know, to pacify the oil..er, I mean, "the crazy terrorists that hate us for our freedom". I don't know if this theory has any merit or not, but it certainly seems likely that interested parties of many stripes semi-regularly provoke public outrage for economic reasons.