5 ms·
Chomsky, unfortunately, is not the most rigorous guy when it comes to empiricism. Look at how he interpreted the Khmer Rouge genocide http://en.wikipedia.org/w
by mc32 12y ago
Chomsky, unfortunately, is not the most rigorous guy when it comes to empiricism. Look at how he interpreted the Khmer Rouge genocide http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#Chomsky http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#Choms...
He defended them saying that what we said about the Kh R was Western propaganda, etc. Years later, when the truth became undeniable, he defended his actions saying, but well, I couldn't very well know they were so bad and since I didn't have the data, I was still right. Yet, at the time, there we all kinds of information coming out from Kampuchea, all pointing to it being a disaster --even the Vietnamese were utterly alarmed.
So, you really have to be careful with him.
- moo 12y agoI posted this before: Clearly the Cambodian and Indochina people went through an awful period. Pol Pot did extreme things as a leader but the alternative of leaving Lon Nol in power who had people starving was not good either. Whether communism or Islamic fundamentalism, anti-colonialism wars are not fun to live through. Here is a perspective I picked up from the Internet. "A Finnish inquiry commission concludes that 1 million or fewer people died in the Pol Pot period. The commission documented that at least several thousand of those were because of direct military battles with Vietnam. Part of the discrepancy in death figures comes from those who fail to account for the decrease in births that inevitably happens when a population is lacking adequate food and fighting a war. These missed births get counted as deaths in population projections that assume the birth rate did not change." "The United States war in Southeast Asia killed 600,000 people in Cambodia according to the Finnish Inquiry Commission. The total U.S.-caused deaths in Indochina run into the millions." "By 1975, an estimated 10 percent of the Kampuchean population -- 600,000 -- had already died as a result of the Vietnam War. Those 600,000 deaths were caused by U.S. efforts to track down Vietnamese communists. According to the Peter Jennings documentary "The Killing Fields", Cambodia specifically absorbed 500,000 tons of U.S. bombs in the early 1970s." "The U.S.-instigated war -- and the bombings in particular -- also caused the creation of 2 million refugees, who flooded the cities. The cities then came to depend on the U.S. food aid to live because of the war and the inefficiency of the right-wing Lon Nol regime." "Hence, Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge seized power from Lon Nol in 1975 in the worst possible situation: The people were starving, Kampuchea was the poorest country in the world and one-third of its people were refugees." "Executions and other deaths" "The Boston Globe coverage of Pol Pot's death contained this characterization of the Khmer Rouge: "When the Khmer Rouge marched into the capital on April 17, 1975 to establish their agrarian society, they chased out city dwellers at gunpoint, killed anyone suspected of being an intellectual, forced millions into labor camps, and demanded that children inform on their parents. People were often arrested simply for wearing glasses or knowing a foreign language. Money and private property were abolished, schools and temples were shuttered, and medicine and food became scarce. During a nearly four-year reign, as many as 2 million people died of starvation, execution illness or overwork." "Pol Pot did execute between 75,000 and 150,000 people between 1975 and 1979. Most of those executions took place in the context of war between Vietnam and Cambodia.Vietnam invaded in 1978 and threw the Khmer Rouge out of power.The famous skull-pile pictures from Kampuchea come from a policy especially aimed at the Vietnamese.Serious famine followed again after the final Vietnamese invasion of December 1978, and by the time international aid started it was too late for many. A total of 2 million, or 30 percent of the population, died in the 1970s from the U.S. war, the Pol Pot period and Vietnamese invasions." "The United States aided the Khmer Rouge in the 1980s, because they were enemies of U.S. foes, the Vietnamese, who had invaded and ousted the Khmer Rouge in 1979."
- ptaipale 12y agoI'm Finnish and I'm curious about this "Finnish Inquiry Commision" into Cambodia. I haven't heard of such a (government) commission or investigation, and I'm pretty sure that if one ever existed, I'd have heard about it. I tried to google for it, but found nothing very tangible. Incidentally, many of the references to such a supposed Finnish government commission are made by sites (for instance globalresearch.ca) that are currently also repeating Kremlin view about Ukraine.
- moo 12y agoKampuchea: Decade of Genocide: Report of a Finnish Inquiry Commission by Kiljunen, Kimmo (Editor) Publisher: Zed Books, London Date published: 1984 ISBN-13: 9780862322083 ISBN: 0862322081
- ptaipale 12y agoCannot find it in the library system with that malformed ISBN number. It appears rather strange that a "Finnish Government inquiry" would only be published by someone called Zed Books in London.
- moo 12y agoHere is the curriculum vitae of Dr. Kimmo Kiljunen. http://www.secretariagrulacuip.org/web/attachments/article/67/kiljunen.pdf http://www.secretariagrulacuip.org/web/attachments/article/6... Forget the ISBN, search on Kampuchea Inquiry Commission, 1980 - 82. $6 bucks on Amazon. http://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/086232209X/ref=tmm_pap_used_olp_0?ie=UTF8&condition=used&sr=&qid= http://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/086232209X/ref=tmm_pa...
- DenisM 12y agoSingle-sided "news" reports can be right in some cases and wrong in others. Given that there is no way to verify them, they are obviously untrustworthy at that time, even if later they turn out to be correct. When evaluating one-sided reports absent a different perspective, your best bet is to weight in the biases and the track record of the people reporting it. I'm not sure why you have a problem with that line of reasoning. If anything this is empiricism. Even if he was wrong about his stance on KhR, how does that affect validity of the book? The book cites all of its sources and makes its conclusions in broad daylight, so it's entirely possible to have a productive discussion about the contents and the arguments being made, without discuss the person making those arguments.
- mc32 12y agoIt's not as though there were not refugees streaming out of the country recounting the atrocities and the difficulties they faced escaping the regime. Look, the first two years, the KCP itself thought it was illegitimate that it had no name. They didn't even acknowledge they existed. All you have to do is listen the population. When you have thousands of escapees and refugees recounting the same horrible things, it's not a sinister "propaganda plot". I've heard the stories from actual escapees who still have nightmares from when they trudged though unknown jungle for months not knowing if they'd see another day, not less make it out free. Decomposing bodies, where you might see a cow, in previous times, so in all kinds of places, you din't know who might turn you in, hunger, dispossession, etc.
- DenisM 12y agoSadly, there is no shortage of manipulated victim testimonies either, often used to start or perpetuate a war. - Nayirah testimony leading up to the 1st Iraq war [1] - Numerous refugees testimonies leading up to the 2nd Iraq war (WMD, torture reports, etc) - Torrent of testimonies from Ukraine in recent months, e.g. [2] - I heard there is plenty of made-up material coming from Palestine You can see how giving much credence to a single-sourced report is not just un-epistemological, but also plain dangerous in that it can easily make bad situation worse. It's a very interesting question - how do we judge credibility of such reports? Clearly you can't take them at face value, but there must be things we can do. Obviously the best is a number of investigations by multiple independent people on site, but that's not always possible. One thing that comes to mind is interviewing all of the refugees and collating their accounts, as it could give a lot of data - people make errors, but if they all make the same errors it can point to manipulated accounts. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nayirah_%28testimony%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nayirah_%28testimony%29 [2] http://news.yahoo.com/russian-tv-sparks-outrage-ukraine-child-crucifixion-claim-114839196.html http://news.yahoo.com/russian-tv-sparks-outrage-ukraine-chil...