6 ms·
> giving every piece of information a URL Wasn't that supposed to be the whole purpose of URL?
by seba_dos1 12y ago
> giving every piece of information a URL
Wasn't that supposed to be the whole purpose of URL?
- jayzalowitz 12y agoLike some sort of a uniform resource locator?
- askmike 12y agodefinitely, though that doesn't mean it is interesting for humans (Google is a search engine for humans).
- graeme 12y agoDo you, as a human, find the site to be uninteresting? It's very clear to me, and obviously useful. If a number calls me, I can look it up. If anyone else has received calls, I may get information. I've used services like this to find out that certain numbers were spam, others were from my bank, etc. It makes sense to have each number to be a page. How else would you design it? This is of some concern to me as a small webmaster. I have a site with a few pages like this: http://lsathacks.com/explanations/lsat-preptest-73/logical-reasoning-1/q-4/ http://lsathacks.com/explanations/lsat-preptest-73/logical-r... Only the test number, section number and question number change. And of course the text changes completely too, since each page explains a different question. But from headings, the page looks very similar to others. To someone studying for the LSAT, that page is immensely meaningful, and they'll know the difference between 72 and 64 in the context of the LSAT. Just like a human interested in phone number 123-456-7890 will know the difference between that number and 111-456-7890 even though the two numbers may look similar to a machine.
- graeme 12y agoOops. I can't edit. For posterity, I meant to say I have a few thousand pages like the one I linked to. Right now Google has correctly figured out they're useful to list separately. But this whocalledus precedent worries me that someday Google might decide that my pages aren't "different enough" even though there's no better way to arrange them and they were designed for humans.
- mchahn 12y ago> It makes sense to have each number to be a page. How else would you design it? I don't see how it makes any sense to waste an entire page for each number. A simple scrolling list, maybe with numbers that can expand to show more info.
- dlubarov 12y agoI would think 99% of visitors are interested in a single number. Why show them a list of numbers?
- saurik 12y agoThis kind of website does not have a URL for every piece of information: it has a public URL for every potential piece of information, and it expects those to show up in search results. This would be similar to having every combination of words show up in your search results as a blank page on Wikipedia that you can edit to add content. When I use Google to find content, I want to find actual content, not ten billion placeholders: if the site doesn't have information on a particular phone number it should return a 404, not a 200, and not be indexed; there should then be a way to submit information into the database (actual information, not something totally useless like "reported") that then creates that URL. From the home page (which hopefully at this point has high page rank for being a non-spammy resource) they then should link to a list of "updates", which will be seen to change often, and the links on the other end of those will also change often, so Google will pick up new content quickly and efficiently. Yes: I realize that these websites are trying to rely on the search query as their discovery tool to get people to add content, and so doing this "harms" them, but if every one of them does this it becomes a useless discovery tool anyway (as the page of results is just pages and pages of these placeholders); imagine if every wiki did this: chaos.
- whocalledus 12y agoWhich website? whocalled.us does not generate or list any URL that does not have information. Empty pages were never indexed by Google. If you search Google for a random telephone number you will see a ton of empty sites who list every possible number. whocalled.us has never done that.