5 ms·
Your sitemap contains about 1 million URLs. When I look at http://whocalled.us/lookup/2104495665 http://whocalled.us/lookup/2104495665 I see hardly information
by mtmail 12y ago
Your sitemap contains about 1 million URLs. When I look at http://whocalled.us/lookup/2104495665 http://whocalled.us/lookup/2104495665 I see hardly information other than the phone number itself. And Google Adsense advertising. Most of the pages look exactly the same. The ones linked on the homepage contain profanity. The category pages, e.g. http://whocalled.us/lookup/sanantonio http://whocalled.us/lookup/sanantonio are just lists of numbers.
From the outside it looks like a typical content database where every entry is a page with advertising. I can imagine those are no longer in the new Google algorithm's favor. What makes you think your website deserves to be listed on
The usual process to get Google employees to reconsider indexing the website again is called a reconsideration request https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/35843?hl=en https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/35843?hl=en
"I've been making websites since before Google existed, and it feels like my ways are going extinct."
Yes I think creating content databases and giving every piece of information a URL and adding untargeted Adsense is no longer a business. Spammers (not whocalled.us) have been misusing that SEO tactic for too long.
- barry-cotter 12y ago> The usual process to get Google employees to reconsider indexing the website again is called a reconsideration request https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/35843?hl=en https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/35843?hl=en Doesn't that just get filed to dev/null and marked closed after being sent some copypasta that suggests no one ever read the email? That does seem to be the Google Way.
- whocalledus 12y agoAfter the first few reconsideration requests, I questioned whether they were truly read by a human. The time between request and response was often the same, but not always. Whether I wrote a descriptive formal reasoning for reconsideration, or simply "You're idiots.", I still received the same exact template message: > Reconsideration request for http://whocalled.us/ http://whocalled.us/: Site violates Google's quality guidelines > February 14, 2015 > Google received a reconsideration request from a site owner for http://whocalled.us/ http://whocalled.us/. > We've reviewed your site and we believe that http://whocalled.us/ http://whocalled.us/ still violates our quality guidelines. These guidelines outline illicit practices which may lead Google to take action on a site in order to keep webspam out of search results. In order to preserve the quality of our search engine, pages from http://whocalled.us/ http://whocalled.us/ may not appear or may not rank as highly in Google's search results, or may otherwise be considered to be less trustworthy than sites which follow the quality guidelines. > Please correct or remove all content that is outside our quality guidelines. Keep in mind that simply deleting all of your site’s content and immediately requesting reconsideration will not lead to success. Instead we recommend that you spend considerable time and effort to make sure your site provides original, valuable content for users. In order to have a successful reconsideration request, you will need to show that your updated site contains content that does not violate our guidelines. > For more specific information about the status of your site, visit the Manual Actions page in Webmaster Tools. From there, you may request reconsideration of your site again when you believe your site no longer violates the quality guidelines.
- PauloManrique 12y agoDid they provide a specific URL? I remember once being blocked by adsense because of a swimsuit artwork from beach volleyball game (yes), and even after removing it, they kept me blocked until that specific link returned a 404 on the header (before my 404 page wasn't doing that header).
- whocalledus 12y agoI know what you mean, the site has also been blocked by AdSense and I've had to find the specific offending items to remove. But in those cases I think they provided me with some example links. With "Pure Spam", they've determined you to be a black hat SEO spammer, so they do not share any information to help you evade the ban. This makes it difficult for the falsely accused to know how to fix their site. I thought that's why they have manual reviews, but I've sent many reconsideration requests, and no person has ever responded with any specific information to help me know what to do.
- seba_dos1 12y ago> giving every piece of information a URL Wasn't that supposed to be the whole purpose of URL?
- jayzalowitz 12y agoLike some sort of a uniform resource locator?
- askmike 12y agodefinitely, though that doesn't mean it is interesting for humans (Google is a search engine for humans).
- graeme 12y agoDo you, as a human, find the site to be uninteresting? It's very clear to me, and obviously useful. If a number calls me, I can look it up. If anyone else has received calls, I may get information. I've used services like this to find out that certain numbers were spam, others were from my bank, etc. It makes sense to have each number to be a page. How else would you design it? This is of some concern to me as a small webmaster. I have a site with a few pages like this: http://lsathacks.com/explanations/lsat-preptest-73/logical-reasoning-1/q-4/ http://lsathacks.com/explanations/lsat-preptest-73/logical-r... Only the test number, section number and question number change. And of course the text changes completely too, since each page explains a different question. But from headings, the page looks very similar to others. To someone studying for the LSAT, that page is immensely meaningful, and they'll know the difference between 72 and 64 in the context of the LSAT. Just like a human interested in phone number 123-456-7890 will know the difference between that number and 111-456-7890 even though the two numbers may look similar to a machine.
- graeme 12y agoOops. I can't edit. For posterity, I meant to say I have a few thousand pages like the one I linked to. Right now Google has correctly figured out they're useful to list separately. But this whocalledus precedent worries me that someday Google might decide that my pages aren't "different enough" even though there's no better way to arrange them and they were designed for humans.
- quicklyfrozen 12y agoThen Google should stop letting them use adsense, not delist them. I looked up a number that recently called me: http://whocalled.us/lookup/2126621932 http://whocalled.us/lookup/2126621932 Not much info, but enough to know not to answer :-).
- akshatpradhan 12y ago>Not much info Exactly, not much info, which is subpar of the quality that Google wants to index.
- pmelendez 12y agoIn http://www.google.com/about/company/philosophy/ http://www.google.com/about/company/philosophy/ Google states that "Democracy on the web works": "We assess the importance of every web page using more than 200 signals and a variety of techniques, including our patented PageRank™ algorithm, which analyzes which sites have been “voted” to be the best sources of information by other pages across the web. " If they are deciding what is good content or not, that doesn't sound too much "Democratic" to me. They have the right to index whatever they want, but by doing that I have to return to the early ages of the web when we had to consolidate information from different search engines.
- skybrian 12y agoThis is basically a wiki, but with lots of low quality pages. Perhaps shrinking the sitemap to phone numbers that have actual information would help?
- codexon 12y agoBut if the phone numbers weren't on Google when they had 0 comments, then who would be the first to put down a comment? It is the chicken and egg problem.
- skybrian 12y agoWhat it comes down to is that you can't rely on Google for that, any more than Wikipedia could spam Google with a bunch of blank pages as a strategy to get passers-by to fill them in. People who already know about whocalled.us and use it regularly will have to seed it. (Disclaimer: personal opinion; no actual knowledge.)
- codexon 12y ago1. The pages actually gives you geographical information even if there are no comments. 2. Knowing that you are the first person to complain about a number is also informative. If I google a number that no one has complained about, is it better to return 0 results, or at least some of these phone number websites without any comments? I would argue the latter is better. 3. Is it really appropriate for Google to ban an entire domain like this? They can arbitrarily decide that you can't have pages organized in a particular manner and have your whole domain banned?
- whocalledus 12y agoExactly. But if you search a telephone number you should be given new information, not an empty page for you to fill out. Otherwise we end up with the situation we have now, where there's endless empty pages in the search results.
- whocalledus 12y agoI chose not to list any page without at least 1 reported phonecall or comment. Competitors instead listed empty pages, and that is why they beat whocalled.us to the top results in Google, and gained much more traffic. I thought it was spammy to list empty pages, and could not bring myself to do it. But the sites that do that are still indexed, and whocalled.us is not. mysql whocalled -e 'select count(*) as empty from sitemap s left join comment c using(phonenumber) left join phonecall p using(phonenumber) where c.id is null and p.id is null' +-------+ | empty | +-------+ | 0 | +-------+
- solve 12y ago"From the outside it looks like a typical content database..." You would terribly fail, if you were one of Google's paid quality raters. The task is to rate the actual value to the user, regardless of the particulars. The task is NEVER to take lazy shortcuts like you've done and judge a site based on any superficial features, no matter what. You attitude and excuses for Google makes the internet worse for everyone. Please stop being among the people to spread this lazy attitude.
- 27182818284 12y ago> every piece of information a URL and adding untargeted Adsense is I vaguely recall rap genius (now just Genius) getting in trouble for this.
- whocalledus 12y agoI'll be the first one to critique whocalled.us, and tell you all the ways it could be much better. But that is a different issue than whether or not Google should completely remove it from its search results. That page you linked to is mostly useless, and I would prefer to remove it from the index. But if I search that same phone number on Google, the #1 result is an empty page, "Be the first to comment:" (http://www.callhunter.com/numbers/2104495665 http://www.callhunter.com/numbers/2104495665). There are plenty of pages that have a lot more information. Try this one (http://whocalled.us/lookup/6023888058 http://whocalled.us/lookup/6023888058). It is a messy site, with profanity, and plenty of noisy data. But how is that "Pure Spam" as Google insists? I'll gladly reorganize the site if there's a significant problem with how it's structured. But Google has indexed this website in this same form for many years, and it continues to index its competitors. Why delete it now? They might've detected something I have not found yet, but why not tell me so I can fix it? They provide me with no specifics about why whocalled.us is "Pure Spam".