6 ms·
A Russian TV Insider Describes a Modern Propaganda Machine
- Red_Tarsius 12y ago> “What they are basically trying to undermine is the idea of a reality-based conversation,” Mr. Pomerantsev said, “and to use the idea of a plurality of truths to feed disinformation, which in the end looks to trash the information space.”
- lawl 12y agoWar is Peace Freedom is Slavery Ignorance is Strength
- kingmanaz 12y ago"Diversity is our strength". Fits right in. https://www.peaceproject.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/product_full/LS99-Diversity-is-our-Strength-Large-Bumper-Sticker.jpg https://www.peaceproject.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/...
- thatsjustcrazy 12y agoGee willickers, I sure am glad nothing like that happens here in the good old US of A.
- lawl 12y ago> During Mr. Putin’s first stint in the presidency, slick techniques imported from the West helped engineer a spectacular rise in his approval ratings (emphasis mine)
- efbbbf 12y agoWell, with Russia's already severe lack of independent media or freedom of speech and the active repression of both, things are certainly looking a lot bleaker than anywhere in the west, including the US.
- calibraxis 12y agoThe problem with US propaganda (like New York Times) is the US is the far more powerful mafia boss than say Russia. (Just look at militant attacks which reach across the world, not to mention incarceration.) Furthermore, people should be concerned with their own country's criminality, not hypocritically pointing the finger at official enemies like Russia. (As this is a US-dominated forum.)
- nothrabannosir 12y agoHow much karma do you need on HN to downvote? Because this deserves one. How often are we going to repeat this point? Okay, as slowly and clearly as I can: "Two wrongs don't make a right." Just because the US does bad thing X, doesn't mean we can't talk about another country doing bad thing X. Please, for the love of baby Jesus and his family. Please. Please. I won't even top it off with a "the country's people are not the same as its government," or anything like it. I just beg of you, please, please stop using this line of reasoning. I'm so exhausted of seeing it. It wears me down. PS: GP has a point, he sketches the context. Fine. "Russia is not the only one, also US." Okay, it's true. But when you say "don't talk about Russia, because US!" then no. No, no, no, no. No. EDIT: Can't reply to "rational-future", so I'll say it here: No, not at all. The opposite. As I said: "GP has a point". My problem is here: > Furthermore, people should be concerned with their own country's criminality, not hypocritically pointing the finger at official enemies like Russia. This is wrong. Telling people to shut up because their government / countrymen / ... does the same thing. Sure, call them out for being hypocrites. But even hypocrites have a right to speak. So, yeah: do talk about the US. Sure. Give me context. As long as you leave all the room for the original discussion.
- rational-future 12y agoSo you're saying "Don't talk US, because Russia"?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- astazangasta 12y agoLet's never forget the aggressive narrative-peddling by New York Times that brought us into war in Iraq.
- blumkvist 12y agoNice commenting history.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoNo, actually it doesn't... This stuff may be going on inside Fox News, and I doubt that. But that would be a single TV channel. In Russia they coordinate among all TV channels and there is no dissenting voice. The superiority of western media over what is available from Russia or similar countries is not in the honesty and quality of any single media outfit, but in the plurality of media voices. In the west, there are so many channels, shows, magazines and online sites, financed by completely different means, often pulling in different political directions, that most attempts at disinformation are discovered sooner rather than later.
- Mikeb85 12y agohttp://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent We in the west are far more brainwashed than we think...
- cnp 12y agoYeah, so true. Its not like all of our news is being piped through top-level editorial departments of major corporate conglomerations or anything, or this video of dozens of news anchors reading a shared script is real.... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PStpvviPgxk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PStpvviPgxk
- bayesianhorse 12y agoIf you know you are brainwashed, you obviously know the "truth". So how come you know the truth but believe the truth isn't told? You see my point?
- Mikeb85 12y ago> If you know you are brainwashed, you obviously know the "truth". We never really know the truth. I can tell you what I ate this morning, and I can tell you that the sky is blue (maybe blue-greyish today). The point is that too many people believe what they see on CNN, and assume it's the absolute truth. People base their world view upon curated news without questioning anything. Here's a great interview by Larry King on his Ora TV network (re-broadcast online by RT): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wv2f6ZZmx4A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wv2f6ZZmx4A In it, Stephen Cohen (the guest) makes the point that there's little debate in the western media these days. Either you agree, or you agree more. No one questions anything anymore. Russians will tell you everything is a lie not because everything in Russia IS a lie (some things are, some aren't - much like over here), but because it's part of Russian culture, their outlook on the world, to be cynical and critical of everything. One poster brought up that RT is trying to discredit everything, but that's not really correct. Russians question everything, it's a part of slavic culture, hell my 92 year old Ukrainian grandfather who's been here his whole life shares that outlook. We in the west though have been transformed into gullible sheep, who question nothing we're told because we are comfortable working our 9-5 (more like 7-6) job to pay off our credit cards and debt, while watching shitty TV shows and never finding the motivation to ever learn about anything...
- henriquemaia 12y agoStrongly related: Adam Curtis' short documentary shown during Charlie Brooker's 2014 Wipe program – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcy8uLjRHPM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcy8uLjRHPM
- cnp 12y agoThis right here should be voted right to the top.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoFunny story: In Germany there is currently a "movement" of people calling for stricter immigration control (to abbreviate an endless discussion about what they actually want), called Pegida. During one of their demonstrations a comedy/satire show dressed up an actor as a "Russian" journalist from "Russia Today", a news caster/online magazine financed by the Russian state. The Pegida participants were very willing to talk to him. They said that western media is all corrupt and unfree, and that Russia Today is a "welcome" and more honest alternative. Which is so far from the truth it isn't even funny.
- rational-future 12y agoYou're funny as well :) RT, BBC, Al Jazeera are official state propaganda machines, but that doesn't mean ALL they say is propaganda. As a matter of personal opinion on many subjects (not directly connected with the Russian government) RT is more honest than the big international media outlets (that cant afford to alienate the western governments, big advertisers or powerful interest groups).
- lispm 12y agoRT is pure propaganda. We have now a German program by RT. Website: http://www.rtdeutsch.com http://www.rtdeutsch.com Straight from Putin's mouth...
- blumkvist 12y agoThe situation is a lot worse in post-soviet countries in the EU like Bulgaria and Romania. When the regime fell the same people who ruled during that era staged everything so they remained in power. From political and official power to power through capital and corruption. A known mafia boss (Delyan Peevski) has control of over 50% of the newspapers and 80% of the distribution of all newspapers through another company. All the attorney generals of Bulgaria have been obviously corrupt, having dinners with prominent mafia bosses on yachts, etc. Everything in the judiciary system is made corrupt by design. All forms of opposition are crushed in infancy either by propaganda, intimidation or infiltrating the opposing organization and breaking it from the inside. It's HELL. We don't know what to do. When we think the situation can't be any more dire, another, greater scandal is already looming. It's depressing and crushing.
- fragsworth 12y ago> a prominent news anchor reviewed the coming events as if they were part of a film script, musing on how best to entertain the audience and questioning who that week’s enemy should be. Having avoided traditional American news sources for a long time (10+ years), whenever I get a glimpse of it now (especially cable news sources), I always got the sense that this is exactly how American news is produced.
- rational-future 12y agoRussia is a small country (as population and industry) compared to US and EU. It cant afford to reinvent the way a modern society, government, media, etc. works. The state propaganda machine is a direct copy of what the US and especially the UK governments have built.
- icebraining 12y agoI find it funny how you're trying to defend RT and Russia (which is fine), but managed to make the most damning criticism of the whole thread :) Poor Russia, the first country to put a man in space, now reduced to copying propaganda machines!
- rational-future 12y agoI'm not trying to defend anyone. Russia is as evil as the US, it just doesn't have enough hardware to do as much damage. The man in space flew on a rocket initially designed in Nazi Germany.
- maxxxcohen 12y agoYou sound like such a racist..
- jackweirdy 12y agoTroll accounts on HN too now? (Check the twitter account on the profile page)
- detcader 12y agoMeanwhile the NYT hosts a tiny AP story on the new Reporters Without Borders report, under the "Europe" section [1]. Russia is rated much lower than the US, but we are not free from embarrassment. See Glenn Greenwald's commentary [2]. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2015/02/12/world/europe/ap-eu-europe-press-freedom.html http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2015/02/12/world/europe/ap-e... [2] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/02/12/u-s-drops-49th-world-press-freedom-rankings-second-lowest-ever/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/02/12/u-s-drops-49th...
- DangerousPie 12y agoThe headline sounds very interesting but I was actually quite disappointed by the article itself. It doesn't offer any concrete examples or any attempt to actually validate what this guy is saying. It also doesn't even attempt to compare this to what the media landscape looks like in other countries. If all that happened was that a "prominent news anchor reviewed the coming events as if they were part of a film script, musing on how best to entertain the audience and questioning who that week’s enemy should be" then this doesn't sound too different from what probably happens in some US news rooms as well. I have no trouble believing that Russian TV is a propaganda machine and projects like the World Press Freedom Index [1] tend to agree. But this seems like a very weak article to make this point. [1] http://rsf.org/index2014/en-index2014.php http://rsf.org/index2014/en-index2014.php
- imissmyjuno 12y agoI find it amusing that an article that's supposed to criticize a controlled media system is itself a thinly veiled advertisement. I guess mass media has issues everywhere you look :)
- DenisM 12y agoNew York times regularly publishes book reviews. They even have that thing they call "NYT Bestsellers" [1]. I'm not sure why that seems problematic to you? [1] http://www.nytimes.com/best-sellers-books/ http://www.nytimes.com/best-sellers-books/
- gwern 12y agoAs a book review, it's a near-complete failure. You hear very little about what the book recounts about Russian propaganda, which is the main interest; instead we get fluff about his school chess club used his Sovietness to intimidate others. That may be a cute biographical detail fine for a book, but is a waste of limited space in a book review.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoPlugging a book is hardly an issue comparable to for example 200 murdered journalists...
- DenisM 12y agoPublic indoctrination through control of the media is easily the most pressing problem of our days. Far more important than that of the global warming, for example, simply because it blocks meaningful discussion on the subjects that really matter. While the public opinion is manipulated both in the US and in Russia, the methods and outcomes are vastly different. For a diligent study of the US media manipulation I highly recommend Chomsky's book "Understanding Power" [2]. You may disagree with his opinions, but they are still worthy of consideration because Chomsky backs up each observation with a verifiable reference, to the point where all of the references combined make an entire separate book of equal volume. If you don't like Chomsky's answers, you will at least appreciate the questions he's trying to tackle. I haven't read the headline book yet [1], but it has the potential to shed some light on how things are done over in Russia. Between the two works, I hope, one can gain actual knowledge of the methods of the public opinion manipulation. The kind of knowledge to replace both the blind faith in the media and it's twin brother - the entirely counterproductive nihilistic disregard of all news. [1] "Nothing Is True and Everything Is Possible", Peter Pomerantsev http://www.amazon.com/Nothing-Is-True-Everything-Possible/dp/1610394550 http://www.amazon.com/Nothing-Is-True-Everything-Possible/dp... [2] http://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Power-Indispensible-Chomsky-Noam-ebook/dp/B003XU7IFY http://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Power-Indispensible-Chom...
- mc32 12y agoChomsky, unfortunately, is not the most rigorous guy when it comes to empiricism. Look at how he interpreted the Khmer Rouge genocide http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#Chomsky http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#Choms... He defended them saying that what we said about the Kh R was Western propaganda, etc. Years later, when the truth became undeniable, he defended his actions saying, but well, I couldn't very well know they were so bad and since I didn't have the data, I was still right. Yet, at the time, there we all kinds of information coming out from Kampuchea, all pointing to it being a disaster --even the Vietnamese were utterly alarmed. So, you really have to be careful with him.
- moo 12y agoI posted this before: Clearly the Cambodian and Indochina people went through an awful period. Pol Pot did extreme things as a leader but the alternative of leaving Lon Nol in power who had people starving was not good either. Whether communism or Islamic fundamentalism, anti-colonialism wars are not fun to live through. Here is a perspective I picked up from the Internet. "A Finnish inquiry commission concludes that 1 million or fewer people died in the Pol Pot period. The commission documented that at least several thousand of those were because of direct military battles with Vietnam. Part of the discrepancy in death figures comes from those who fail to account for the decrease in births that inevitably happens when a population is lacking adequate food and fighting a war. These missed births get counted as deaths in population projections that assume the birth rate did not change." "The United States war in Southeast Asia killed 600,000 people in Cambodia according to the Finnish Inquiry Commission. The total U.S.-caused deaths in Indochina run into the millions." "By 1975, an estimated 10 percent of the Kampuchean population -- 600,000 -- had already died as a result of the Vietnam War. Those 600,000 deaths were caused by U.S. efforts to track down Vietnamese communists. According to the Peter Jennings documentary "The Killing Fields", Cambodia specifically absorbed 500,000 tons of U.S. bombs in the early 1970s." "The U.S.-instigated war -- and the bombings in particular -- also caused the creation of 2 million refugees, who flooded the cities. The cities then came to depend on the U.S. food aid to live because of the war and the inefficiency of the right-wing Lon Nol regime." "Hence, Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge seized power from Lon Nol in 1975 in the worst possible situation: The people were starving, Kampuchea was the poorest country in the world and one-third of its people were refugees." "Executions and other deaths" "The Boston Globe coverage of Pol Pot's death contained this characterization of the Khmer Rouge: "When the Khmer Rouge marched into the capital on April 17, 1975 to establish their agrarian society, they chased out city dwellers at gunpoint, killed anyone suspected of being an intellectual, forced millions into labor camps, and demanded that children inform on their parents. People were often arrested simply for wearing glasses or knowing a foreign language. Money and private property were abolished, schools and temples were shuttered, and medicine and food became scarce. During a nearly four-year reign, as many as 2 million people died of starvation, execution illness or overwork." "Pol Pot did execute between 75,000 and 150,000 people between 1975 and 1979. Most of those executions took place in the context of war between Vietnam and Cambodia.Vietnam invaded in 1978 and threw the Khmer Rouge out of power.The famous skull-pile pictures from Kampuchea come from a policy especially aimed at the Vietnamese.Serious famine followed again after the final Vietnamese invasion of December 1978, and by the time international aid started it was too late for many. A total of 2 million, or 30 percent of the population, died in the 1970s from the U.S. war, the Pol Pot period and Vietnamese invasions." "The United States aided the Khmer Rouge in the 1980s, because they were enemies of U.S. foes, the Vietnamese, who had invaded and ousted the Khmer Rouge in 1979."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- everyone 12y agoHey everyone check out this documentary film!! https://vimeo.com/67739294 https://vimeo.com/67739294 Experienced investigative journalist John Pilger looks at and questions (among other things) the British medias role as a dumb mouthpiece for the government leading up to and during the invasion of Iraq. EDIT: link has been fixed
- smutticus 12y agoYour link is, while great, completely unrelated.
- Tarang 12y agoIts like a news source version of the Byzantine General's problem. When it comes to Ukraine there's so much doubtfulness in the accuracy of everything because both sides are so contradictory. I don't think it is that simple to just trust one side's story
- sam88 12y agoNytimes is a very crude propaganda machine, I hope one day a decent person would expose them.
- ptaipale 12y agoRegarding Russia's foreign propaganda, a Russian-born person (I think he may not wish to be named) described the situation like this: " Many have wondered why the Russian propaganda machine is spewing out a torrent of such preposterous claims that few people take seriously. They know it will not be believed abroad. The purpose is not that it is believed. The purpose of disinformation was is to destroy trust in all media. Create a space where nobody believes in anything. Then, when people brag that they don't believe the Kremlin propaganda, but also they don't believe "the other propaganda" that is published by media in countries where there is a free press, the information war has been won. If you think that Western media (for purposes of translation: let's take for example DW or BBC) is as unreliable as Russia Today, you are not above the information war. You are its casualty. " And seeing the preposterous claims about persecution of ethnic Russians where I live, contra reality of ethnic Russian people I know, and how some people still keep reminding how also the Western TV channels and papers are part of a propaganda machine... he has a strong point.
- mc32 12y agoThat is their greatest achievement, to gain equivalency. To a good degree this has worked. There are lots of people who believe major European and NorthAmerican media are no better than Russian media. It has worked for their domestic audience, to great effect, and to a good degree internationally. Just look at Putin's approval ratings.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoI don't really believe Putin's approval ratings. In Russia there is no free press and private companies or academic institutes can be controlled at will by the executive branch. So if any institute or private company conducts a poll... well...
- mc32 12y agoI'm afraid I believe the role of the Emp(eror/ress)/Tsar(ina)/Premier/President in Russia is akin to the role of a Father-at-large. So basically, people know he's flawed, they're not innocent, afterall, but they feel protective of him. They take him personally. So an attack on him, by the media, by western institutions, are, indirectly an indictment on them. I think this has foundation in how the country has always had a strongman or strongwoman at the helm who have always projected their power unambiguously and forcefully. It has been this way since the Khievan Rus. People were for practical purposes enslaved serfs till 1917. And then it arguably got worse.
- moo 12y agoThe U.S. has been in perpetual war for over a decade, the media is part of that war. While advantaged, educated U.S. citizens want to make believe in a free Western press, invented narratives like Jessica Lynch rescue, staged Saddam Hussein statue toppling, Diane Sawyer's yellow journalism showing bombed out Gaza calling it Israel, BBC filming actors in supposed Syrian gas attack, embedded media to show our boys in a positive light, Brian Williams lie to also make war personal for viewers that was shot down by soldiers over "stolen valor", these incidents paint a different picture. How about how journalist Helen Thomas who was set up to discredit her. 6 corporations control 90% of media in U.S. Is that the diversity Nuland crows about. Journalists and academics are often found to be paid agents of intelligence services.
- Htsthbjig 12y agoAny big media is a propaganda machine, starting by the New York Times, that is broke and easily controlled by those that sustain it. The US of A invaded Iraq and Afghanistan because somewhat a modern propaganda machine convinced Americans that because 21 guys coming from a friendly dictatorship nation decided to kill themselves in planes, they needed to invade another different country with probably the biggest oil reserves today. Of course the modern propaganda machine tried very hard to convince people that controlling the oil was not the important part. That more than 5000 Americans and a million Iraqis died and more than a trillion dollars was spent because of "freedom". Remember "war on terror" propaganda? Remember weapons of mass destruction invention? Remember Osama Bin Laden that appeared and disappeared as was needed and then died when needed(and nobody independent saw the body before being buried in secret in the Ocean).
- mahranch 12y ago> Remember "war on terror" propaganda? Sure do. It was largely spun by a single entity which wasn't state-owned (Fox News). And it was criticized by other agencies for doing so (MSNBC, CNN, Hell the Dailyshow made it their mission). Let's see RussiaToday's competitors (do they have any?) criticize RussiaToday for defending the Ukraine situation. The entire organization would probably end up in a ditch somewhere, having died in a fatal plane crash. Sorry, but as much as you want to equate the two, they are not remotely the same. To hold the belief that they are means the person lacks critical thought.
- guard-of-terra 12y agoDid I just read 10 pages random guy bio? With one-liner about a question from the title.
- Mikeb85 12y agoThis whole article is rubbish by the way. This guy grew up in London, and here the article describes his TV experience: > FOR a time, at least, Mr. Pomerantsev, now 37, seems also to have been at home in the raucous world of middlebrow Russian television, making films about gold-digging women (hunting men known as “Forbeses” — as in the Forbes list of the wealthy), ruthless gangsters and sinister cults. From the sounds of it, he never even worked on news programs, just producing TV shows and movies. And this is someone the NY Times considers an 'expert' to 'uncover' the Russian propaganda machine? While you want to talk propaganda, how about maybe bringing up the fact that this guy is a Brit. He lives in London, and his family moved away from the Soviet Union before it broke up. How about you talk about the fact he wrote a book, is obviously trying to drum up sales by virtue of the fact he's writing about propaganda while he was himself personally involved in low-brow TV shows. Yet this makes it to the NY Times and front page of HN by virtue of? It's like getting a producer of real housewives of whatever to talk about US coverage of the Iraq war... tl;dr - this guy produced shows about: > making films about gold-digging women (hunting men known as “Forbeses” — as in the Forbes list of the wealthy), ruthless gangsters and sinister cults. What does he know about propaganda... And HN is eating this up, talking about Russian propaganda like this article had something to say.
- moo 12y agoWe have engineered GMO food so why not engineered news media? Free speech is really a mechanism to protect advertisers. As I feel myself as a sort of penned livestock that gets to choose between competing capitalists, all I can say is I'm off Western news media as it gives me diarrhea, but if you can consume it then more power to you.
- pluma 12y agoJust like GMO is merely a continuation of the manual engineering ("cultivation") that has been going on since the earliest days of human societies, biased media is nothing new at all, sadly. Although the Luddites would have you think it's a novel problem, news never where unbiased in the first place. Sure, good journalistic self-control can go a long way in preserving the original information, but that information in itself is biased already. There's another analogy about processed food and processed information here, but it's still a matter of where you can source what you can consume. Buying local means you'll have to abstain from foreign material, which I don't think is an option for many when it comes to news.