2 ms·
> You'll never know all of the data either. "The data is fixed" refers only to the data we know. (Otherwise, as you point out, there would be no issue since we
by pdonis 12y ago
> You'll never know all of the data either.
"The data is fixed" refers only to the data we know. (Otherwise, as you point out, there would be no issue since we would simply calculate the population statistics directly.) In the frequentist model, we have to pretend that this fixed data is actually a random distribution in order to calculate the probability we're interested in. In the Bayesian model, we just combine the known data with the prior to get the posterior probability; we don't have to pretend anything.
- quacker 12y ago> "The data is fixed" refers only to the data we know. Okay, yeah. The sample is fixed. The entire population is random. I'll use this terminology. > In the frequentist model, we have to pretend that this fixed data is actually a random distribution With confidence intervals, we're modelling the entire population as a random distribution, using the fixed sample's mean and variance to compute estimates of the population's mean and variance. I think this is different than "pretending the sample is random". If you constructed a normal model of the sample, you would just use the sample's mean and standard deviation. But to model the population, you typically use the sample's standard error as an estimate of the population's standard deviation. This is critical. You have to account for the fact that the population is much larger than your sample.