In that case I don't see how the image format ties into any of what you just said. Seems to me the image format is completely irrelevant. Docker's format could

In that case I don't see how the image format ties into any of what you just said. Seems to me the image format is completely irrelevant. Docker's format could be augmented to include all the security features you want and rkt could just use docker containers. That's where the confusion is. It is clear that the image format is orthogonal to all the other issues you mentioned. By the way I don't have a dog in this race and am not rooting for either side. Just from purely a technical perspective and resource use the fragmentation is now starting to feel something that is mostly driven by public relations and marketing. As someone that tries to use the best tool for the job I now have no compelling reason to choose either format and run-time which means I'm just going to wait it out and both sides are going to lose contributions from independent open source developers because their effort is going to be wasted.