6 ms·
The Pursuit of Beauty: Yitang Zhang solves a pure-math mystery
- raincom 12y agoYes, he is a different class. Different from all those mathematicians working at Harvard, Princeton, etc. That adjunct job gave him sanity to solve the problem. In the case of Grigori Perelman, these universities (Princeton, Harvard) did not want to give tenure job after his proving Soul Conjecture; this was during his postdoc at Courant NYU. Of course, these math guys wanna offer a tenure track position, which woulda prevented him from proving Poincare conjecture. He went back to Russia, spent time in isolation for 8 years or so. Proved it. Once he published the paper on arXiv, the shithead professors at Princeton, Columbia want him back, so that they can be co-authors of his paper on poincare conjecture or these universities can appear on the paper a la affliation: you see, these elite universities love to show "Mr X from Princeton solved poincare conjecture". Another chinese professor at Harvard tried to steal the credit from Perelman for the same conjecture. It is a big mess out there. Zhang somehow used his adjunct/tutor job to spend time in number theory. Perelman used his postdoc fellowship savings to solve his problem. IN Zhang's case, he got the tenureship after his proof; Perelman gave up math.
- Ronsenshi 12y agoThank you for you comment. Very interesting information just like the article itself.
- jdonaldson 12y agoIt's pretty damning evidence if two of the biggest math breakthroughs needed to occur outside of our best universities. Arxiv is turning into a great tool to spread academic ideas, and is in some ways replacing the role of traditional journals. However, how do we replace the funding side of the equation? In both of these breakthrough cases, it seems the researchers found a loophole or used their personal savings.
- hybridthesis 12y agoI assume by "chinese professor at Harvard tried to steal the credit from Perelman", you mean the defamatory article written by The New Yorker regarding on Shing-Tung Yau. That accusatory article was written by an outsider with no regard to reality. For a correct account from within the mathematical community, see http://doctoryau.com/hamiltonletter.pdf http://doctoryau.com/hamiltonletter.pdf.
- littletimmy 12y agoWhile that may be true, there is no denying that Yau is a pretty divisive figure. He seems as interested in building his image in China and making the Chinese nation proud, than he is in doing real math. I can see why this attitude would rub some mathematicians the wrong way.
- raincom 12y agoThere is something unethical about Yau. Here is more: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manifold_Destiny#Revision_of_the_Cao.E2.80.93Zhu_article http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manifold_Destiny#Revision_of_th...
- eng_monkey 12y ago> Mr X from Princeton solved poincare conjecture Most likely Prof or Dr instead of Mr ;-)
- aurizon 12y agoget rid of new yorker = paywall
- ctchocula 12y agoI too have read my last complimentary article of the month, and am stuck behind the paywall. Could someone paste the article here?
- breckinloggins 12y agoHardy's comment about math being a "young man's game" has bothered me since I read his "Course of Pure Mathematics" about 10 years ago. I'm sure there's at least a bit of truth to the statement that mathematical discovery is, in general, easier for younger minds, but it seems to be an unnecessary and harmful trope to propagate. Either you still have it, or you don't. Why does the Fields Medal care about age? If a 60 year old proves the Riemann Hypothesis, why is he or she ineligible? This happened notably with Andrew Wiles. He (indirectly) proved Fermat's Last Theorem and was rewarded a "special plaque" instead of the Fields Medal for the crime of waiting until after his 40th trip around the sun to work on it. There's also the issue of economic pressure. We expect our young minds to solve "real problems" and to want to make a lot of money doing it. Pure mathematicians get to "hide" in academia when times are good and are often on the street when they aren't so good. In the absence of a focus on supporting the arts (including math) through patronage etc it is just hard for young people to get in the field. Older people have more time. Let them create without lowered expectations. For a deeply beautiful subject with a lot of very smart people, this whole age thing is just scratch-your-head puzzling.
- GuiA 12y agoHumans are often silly and irrational and like making up arbitrary rules for the games they play. Don't lose too much time scratching your head about these things, or you'll quickly end up bald.
- dxbydt 12y agoAt the risk of downvotes, I will state a whole bunch of [Citation Needed] BS, which is, nevertheless, empirically true & in Hardy's favor - 1. Cerebral atrophy affects left brain disproportionately more than the right 2. Math is predominantly a left-brain activity. 3. Ergo, short-term memory & dexterity with numbers generally degrades with age ( supposedly peaking at 25 & declining from then on). Most math majors I've spoken to ( from prodigies to professors & people in between ) attest to the fact that they were much sharper when they were quite young. It isn't that they become dumber as they age, more like - they pick up a different kind of math to compensate for some of the other math that required them to exercise their symbolic manipulation skills at superior pace, which they have now lost.
- mrwizrd 12y agoFor anyone behind the paywall, here's a pastebin link. The article was a bit long to break into comments. http://pastebin.com/Xtm3f64E http://pastebin.com/Xtm3f64E
- mhlakhani 12y agoJust googling for the article's title leads to a link that works. They don't paywall people coming from Google
- wornoutman 12y agoCorrect me if I am wrong, but I believe the author made an error. The author wrote: "A prime from which you can remove numbers and still have a prime is a deletable prime, such as 1987". However if you remove the 7, then the number is divisible by 2, so the statement: "A prime from which you can remove numbers and still have a prime is a deletable prime" does not apply to 1987.
- a3_nm 12y agoThe definition given in the article is an informal shortcut, the complete definition is http://mathworld.wolfram.com/DeletablePrime.html http://mathworld.wolfram.com/DeletablePrime.html and 1987 is indeed a deletable prime (see http://oeis.org/A080608/b080608.txt http://oeis.org/A080608/b080608.txt for http://oeis.org/A080608 http://oeis.org/A080608).
- dragonwriter 12y ago> However if you remove the 7, then the number is divisible by 2, so the statement: "A prime from which you can remove numbers and still have a prime is a deletable prime" does not apply to 1987. A deletable prime doesn't require that the deletion order start from the last digit; the deletion order for 1987 is: 1987 -> 197 -> either 19 or 17
- test_plan 12y agoThere's an interesting (and impassioned) critique of this article at http://www.angrymath.com/2015/02/yitang-zhang-article-in-new-yorker.html http://www.angrymath.com/2015/02/yitang-zhang-article-in-new...
- blackbagboys 12y agoCould you perhaps explain what you found interesting? It's an angry screed very revealing of its author's personality, but not particularly insightful about the article.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoI was thinking the same, the blogger appears to have a lot of things he's upset about and is taking them out on the article.
- SixSigma 12y agoOT the cartoons interspersed in the OP are absolutely awful. Nice work if you can get it!
- guelo 12y agoThis author immediately made me hate him starting with the first paragraph. What was the point of that first paragraph? And I'm OK with adding some color throughout to liven up a story but I felt like this author was just wasting my time to try to show off that he's a writer. What an asshole.
- sanoli 12y agoThat first paragraph's tl;dr was basically: I'm bad with numbers, I'm an artist, but someone told me about this math guy with an interesting story.
- eng_monkey 12y agoThe author does not even understand the difference between arithmetic and mathematics.
- aint 12y agoWhat's the difference?
- maxxxcohen 12y agoHow can it be solved , if it's still considered a mystery ?