4 ms·
While I don't always agree with Joel, it is a bit of headline grabbing to call him a snake-oil salesman. He is building a product that is shipping and the comp
by wglb 17y ago
While I don't always agree with Joel, it is a bit of headline grabbing to call him a snake-oil salesman. He is building a product that is shipping and the company is profitable. Not easy to do.
But I think if universities taught CS the way that they should, and not many do, in my opinion, the result might not be what he expects.
I think that many companies misuse programmer talent--one example is to employ thousands (not exaggerating) in enterprise departments that are reduced to moving one field to the other. If there were lots of well-trained CS grads with a better orientation, they might be questioning how things are done. Both in large enterprise situations and perhaps in Joel's company.
His strongest point is that students are not exposed to longer projects. I was once in a position to hire compiler people. Few graduates of programs that taught compilers were well-equipped. One large state university in Michigan taught a compiler course in a semester. The graduates that I talked to came away with the notion that compilers were very scary. Graduates from another midwestern school across the lake did very well. Their compiler course was a full year as part of their masters program.
I think that industry does not really know what to ask for. CICS as part of a CS program? (True). Really?
- wglb 17y agoFor interesting contrast, see http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD08xx/EWD898.html http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD08xx/EW... recently posted here.
- Xichekolas 17y agoWow. "The fact that operating system design posed some at the time tough conceptual and logical problems was hardly allowed to surface. Consequently, those problems did not get the attention they deserved, and this had far-reaching consequences: I recently read a series of articles on the Shuttle on-board software and, though President Reagan has generously offered a teacher a free ride, I tell you I am not available." This talk was given at a conference in mid-November 1984. The flight with a teacher on board was, of course, the Challenger in January of 1986. Of course, the disaster wasn't due to software... but still rather uncanny.