6 ms·
It's a Computer Science degree, not a programming degree. If you want to learn a trade, go to trade school not a four-year university. You wouldn't expect some
by eli 17y ago
It's a Computer Science degree, not a programming degree. If you want to learn a trade, go to trade school not a four-year university.
You wouldn't expect someone with a degree in English to know how to navigate a book contract, would you?
- markdennehy 17y agoNope, I wouldn't. I'd expect them to be able to write the book and then get a lawyer to review the contract that the agent negotiates for them. Mind you, I've not seen degrees in programming as distinct from Computer Science or Computer Engineering over here. We have one, two and three-year diplomas, yes, but degrees are all on the fundamentals over here.
- mellis 17y agoDoesn't programming deserve to be the subject of a rigorous, high-level education? It is a rich craft with a growing tradition. We would do well to consider, as Joel does, how to provide students with appropriate experience for the future practice of their career. That doesn't mean teaching the particular, accidental details of contemporary professional programming, but it does mean taking programming seriously as a subject of education. You can study architecture, design, and engineering in universities - not just sciences and humanities. Similarly, the existence of computer science shouldn't exclude programming from our institutions of higher learning.
- xal 17y agoIt's a trade in Germany. I left school after 10th grade and started my apprenticeship in programming. The net effect is that at 29 i've now been a professional programmer for 12 years. More importantly, I also developed all my programming habits during my formative years and therefore developed pretty good habits that are now hard wired and second nature. It gives me a huge edge over other programmers of my age who have been joining the work force over the last few years.
- tel 17y agoThe huge difference being that in Germany you have functional apprenticeship programs. In the US, which this article is centric to, you're really just going to go to college, have little option besides CS, and then end up somewhere in the chasm of this debate. Trade schools exist, but since they're generally looked down upon you're not going to see a lot of popularity in Programming Trade degrees. Though perhaps the only difference between programming and metal craftsmen is that CS is more obviously popular and valuable these days. P only might equal NP so computers and robots haven't yet taken over the job of crafting programs. This is meant to be a lot less a critique of programming and a lot more a nod toward the intense craft that goes into many of the things you might learn as a "trade". The general skill to build something physical and high quality is so frequently looked down upon these days.
- eli 17y agoI totally get what you're saying, but I'm not actually convinced that it does. There's a certain purity in studying the math and science behind computers instead of studying how to bring your C# program in under deadline.
- gloob 17y agoThat said, in a world where there are degrees in video game design and journalism, theoretical purity is probably not the defining characteristic of subjects that are taught at university.
- MartinCron 17y agoAnd there's no reason that those who are drawn to the purity of math and science behind computers can't attend traditional CS programs. It would be good if real universities could also (as a different department, whatever) provide relevant instruction and research in the realm of programming. Those who really care about both can always double major.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoYou may be "right" in theory, but it doesn't matter. The vast majority of computer science students pursue a CS degree because it has become a prerequisite for being a professional software engineer. NOT because they have a desire to become a computer scientist. The simple fact is that if you do not have a 4-year college degree you will find it immensely harder to work as a software engineer in the industry. It's silly to pretend otherwise. The vast majority of today's CS programs do a disservice to all of their students. They are neither good engineering programs training students for industry (for which they currently serve as a proxy) nor good computer science programs. A recently minted graduate of a Chemistry or Physics program (from an accredited US 4-year college program) is, on average, much more versed in the relevant scientific findings and research techniques of their field than a CS graduate. They are so poor precisely because the vast majority of CS graduates do not go on to do CS research or utilize their CS knowledge but instead become software engineers.
- MartinCron 17y agoWhile I mostly agree with your point, the phrase "Infinitely harder" is a bit of a stretch. I've worked with many professional software engineers without CS degrees, and even many professional software engineers without 4-year degrees at all. Personally, I was already a programmer when I took my first University CS courses and realized quickly that while I love programming, CS isn't where my interests lie. I took the CS courses that were most relevant and wound up getting a business degree. I do wish there were more programs available serving the middle ground between the v-school ghetto and the ivory tower.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoGood point, "infinitely" is a bit hyperbolic, "immensely" fits better, I think. I agree, it is possible to be a professional software engineer without a CS degree (some of the best fit that category), but that's a non-traditional road. More to the point, it's exceedingly rare for someone to intentionally avoid earning a CS degree if they plan, prior to attending college, to become a software developer.
- ramchip 17y ago
- steve19 17y agoComputer Science is to programming that telescopes are to Astronomy. The concepts are what should be taught - not the latest buzzwords.
- mquander 17y agoPerhaps you should brush up on your buzzwords, because you have really eviscerated the meaning from that particular quote.