3 ms·
While I agree it was egregious I think people may be missing the point. The FBI is getting a huge black eye here, Goldman is already losing out. This is how our
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
While I agree it was egregious I think people may be missing the point. The FBI is getting a huge black eye here, Goldman is already losing out. This is how our system works.
Goldman over reached and through their efforts got this guy arrested. That they could do that, is a problem, but now everyone involved has been thoroughly spanked (with some bonus civil case spanking as well it seems). So the next time Goldman call's the FBI, they are going to be treated much more skeptically and the agents in charge are going to be unwilling to do anything based on Goldman's "word". Because the agents will remember this and they do not want to be the butt of interagency jokes, or up on civil liability.
- loopholeclosed 12y agohttp://www.mondaq.com/unitedstates/x/215714/employee+rights+labour+relations/Understanding+The+New+Theft+Of+Trade+Secrets+Clarification+Act+Of+2012 http://www.mondaq.com/unitedstates/x/215714/employee+rights+... They've already "clarified" and "closed" that loophole. Next time, the programmer actually would go to jail.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoIn a meta sense I'm curious why you had to create a new account just to post this, although I know the position that the system we have in place actually does work [1] is unpopular. The system is messy, it doesn't travel in a straight line from broken to fixed, and it takes a lot of time and energy to get right. Consider Prohibition for a moment, it was freaking unconstitutional to drink for a while there. Yes it was broken, yes it got fixed. Just like Marijuana use is getting fixed, slowly, inexorably, fixed. Martin Luther King was jailed by a broken system, and slowly, over time, it has been getting fixed. You cannot see a tree grow, but it does. And many people cannot see that our system of governing is working, but it does. As long as you take the long view, it will. Believe that you are a helpless pawn and all is lost, and it won't. [1] Rights for same sex marriage anyone? Used strong encryption in email?
- loopholeclosed 12y ago> In a meta sense I'm curious why you had to create a new account just to post this Events led me to conclude that using the same account consistently was a bad idea from an employment standpoint. It has nothing to do with this. It is just what I do now. Hell, the password for this account should be easy to guess if you start with the letter a and work your way to the right. > You cannot see a tree grow, but it does. And many people cannot see that our system of governing is working, but it does. As long as you take the long view, it will. Believe that you are a helpless pawn and all is lost, and it won't. It is my belief that wealthy people can (usually) get away with passing whatever crap they want through Congress. The only tool I have at my disposal is point out when this happens and hope people get outraged enough to do something. I'm confused why you view that with a belief that I'm helpless? P.s. Given that I basically gave away the password, this is the last time I'll use the account.
- loopholeclosed 12y agoUpon further reflection, maybe I should just keep using it. Demonstrating that multiple people could have access to the account makes an excellent case for plausible deniability. In the right circumstances a court could compel HN to distinguish between these users (or at least, prove that the "multiple" aspect is a fiction), but the existence of doubt minimalizes the professional risk. This feels like about the right level of security for unpopular political meta-comments of this sort.
- gandalfu 12y agoSo you claim!
- loopholeclosed 12y agoI agree with them. Whoever they happen to be!
- loopholeclosed 12y agoAh, but are we paranoid or in possession of multiple personalities? Then again, the risk of a court is never really a risk. This is perfectly legal. :P
- spinlock 12y agoThese seem to be 2 separate points. The original post said that he was exonerated because the FBI didn't have probable cause to search him. The article you linked said he was exonerated because the statute didn't cover HFT systems. I guess that makes sense if the reason the FBI didn't have probably cause was because they should have known that, even if everything Goldman alleged, he still wouldn't have broken any laws.
- loopholeclosed 12y agoThat seems to be the opinion espoused in the article. It was legal due to a "loophole". > I guess that makes sense if the reason the FBI didn't have probably cause was because they should have known that, even if everything Goldman alleged, he still wouldn't have broken any laws. From the article: > On December 28, 2012, President Obama enacted the Theft of Trade Secrets Clarification Act of 2012, which clarifies the scope of the Economic Espionage Act of 1996 (18 U.S.C. §§ 1831-39). The newly enacted amendments are intended to reverse the recent Second Circuit decision in United States v. Aleynikov, 676 F.3d 71 (2d Cir. 2012). The only way that statement makes sense is if the author believed that the FBI failed due to a lack of the acts alleged by Goldman Sachs being a crime. Imo, anyway.
- spinlock 12y agoI think you're right. That's the only consistent way to read this anyway.
- jqm 12y ago"the next time Goldman calls the FBI, they are going to be treated much more sceptically...." maybe. but I sort of doubt it.