4 ms·
Maybe I'm just not getting it, but why would I want a "Smart Home"? It seems to be a little like a Smart TV, everyone wants more features, but really they're ne
by mrweasel 12y ago
Maybe I'm just not getting it, but why would I want a "Smart Home"? It seems to be a little like a Smart TV, everyone wants more features, but really they're newer going to use the built in voice control or install any apps. We need a few basic feature and the rest just sits their, unused, contributing to the complexity of the device.
I have yet to see an intelligent house feature I would like. I understand that some want a better climate control interface, like the Nest. But I have yet to see a house that have central climate/heating control, and I don't miss it in my own home.
Is it really such an inconvenience to get up to turn on the light or turn the blinders?
- icebraining 12y agoIs it really such an inconvenience to get up to turn on the light or turn the blinders? It can be; if you're incapacitated, for example. But automated lights and blinders also offer other possibilities besides remote interfaces, like waking you up with sunlight instead of an alarm clock. In any case, I agree with you, for now; I do want a smart home, but the current implementations provide very little utility for me. I want a smart home if it can do actual work, like cleaning itself.
- vonmoltke 12y agoThere are potential security applications for things like that. For instance, a randomized on-off pattern for lights in your house to help throw off casual thieves. Or, tying the system to the burglar alarm so that all the lights come on and the blinds open when the alarm goes off in order to bring more unwanted attention to the thieves. As others have mentioned, there is also the light-sensitive timer use case.
- aetherson 12y agoTurning on your lights with a phone app (routinely) is obviously terrible. But I would like to be able to turn on my outdoor front door light from outside when I get home after dark. And I'd like to be able to grant access to people remotely. We have a Nest. It was a gift. Is it useful? Sure, it's way better than our old thermostat, and it's nice that usually it sets the temperature to what we want without our explicit intervention. Is it worth the price? Well, no. But it will presumably get cheaper.
- eitally 12y agoI think those aren't the killer use cases driving this. We've had a rash of home burglaries and car break-ins around the surrounding neighborhoods over the past few months, including burglaries where the thieves first broke into a car and then used the garage door opener to get into the house. I am planning an HA system that includes alerting when doors are opened, as well as motion cameras ... being able to also turn on lights and execute IFTTT/Tasker jobs is icing on the cake, but secondary to my primary goal of knowing who's moving around my house and getting them on camera. ADT/CPI type active monitoring services are largely useless in preventing typically break-ins, and the monthly service fees mount quickly.