15 ms·
Those lessons can be useful, though. You might make the same mistakes.
by pg 19y ago
Those lessons can be useful, though. You might make the same mistakes.
- downer 19y agoOr you might come up with something that works, by avoiding having your mind crammed and distorted by the classical mess.
- akkartik 19y agoIt's one thing to notice that beginners can sometimes make contributions by luck, just by not knowing how hard something is supposed to be. It's another to use this reasoning to glorify lack of knowledge. Whenever I see someone succeed rapidly I assume it isn't a newcomer, that there are depths of effort I cannot yet see.
- downer 19y agoMany, many people have gone into the field to study the traditional techniques, and glorifying this knowledge has not led to AI. I don't think a beginner is going to create AI by "luck". But a beginner's mind is not cluttered in the same way as an expert's. This may be what it takes to get working AI. Expert knowledge is appropriate when discussing proven solutions. AI is speculative at this point.
- anaphoric 19y agoI have taught AI many times now and I must agree. You don't know how many times I have heard a student claim that they have made some type of major advance. But on inspection it usually comes down to something that requires exhaustive search. I think that there is definitely a place for new ideas in the field, but I don't think they will come from complete novices. I think they will come from those who have CRITICALLY read the basic literature. And probably from those who have read more than just the basics too. My own pet peeve on the field now is the over emphasis on asymptotic complexity. Sure its important, but its not exactly an AI result. The scruffies need to make a come back and start coding! See my own meager efforts (http://www.anaphoric.com http://www.anaphoric.com)
- downer 19y agoAmazing how people with all this knowledge still haven't gotten anywhere close to AI. It might even be something simple, overlooked, done a little differently.
- akkartik 19y agoLet us know when you find it. I can't think of any phenomenon less likely area to have a simple algorithm than intelligence.
- mojuba 19y agoIntelligence is about finding algorithms for successful survival within a given environment. It's some sort of a meta-algorithm, although I have no idea if it's simple or not, but we can be sure it does exist.
- downer 19y ago> Let us know when you find it. I can't think of any phenomenon less likely area to have a simple algorithm than intelligence. Cf. Evolution.
- eru 19y ago