4 ms·
I read this in the print edition this afternoon. The expert panel identify one problem with education reform: lack of incentives that will move the key actors w
by tokenadult 17y ago
I read this in the print edition this afternoon. The expert panel identify one problem with education reform: lack of incentives that will move the key actors who could make things better.
"MR. MURRAY: When NIH funding discovers some protein that will cure some disease, it gets snapped up in a heartbeat by big pharmaceutical companies who capitalize on it and make it widely available at a profit. When we have lots of successful experiments in education, the mechanisms for transmitting that success to the broader system don't seem to work very well. Why?
"MR. KLEIN: In part because there are not competitive influences that drive it. In a public-delivery system like ours, competition is not typically a driver."
- timwiseman 17y agoThat seems to be the core of the argument of the article. In particular, it seems to drive at saying we need to be able to have more variation in teacher pay in order to attract the best talent, particularly in the STEM areas.
- tptacek 17y agoStudies have been done (Kohn cites one in "The Folly Of Merit Pay") that show more teachers are driven out of teaching by the unintended negative consequences of performance-based pay than are attracted to it by the prospect of more money. It's not hard to see why. Every performance measurement scheme we have today, from federal, state, and municipal school grading to "value-added" schemes, has produced a nightmare of standardized testing and teach-the-test regimes that have crowded out experiments from curricula. You don't have to agree with Alfie Kohn to recognize the problem. Saying "we need to compensate the best teachers to incentivize them" is like saying "we need cars that consume far less gasoline". It's the "how" that's the question.
- tokenadult 17y agoYou don't have to agree with Alfie Kohn to recognize the problem. You also don't have to disagree with Alfie Kohn about his ideas on "performance pay" to think that it makes sense in the New York City job market to pay a math teacher more than, say, a social studies teacher. To get a decent math teacher at all probably requires a salary sufficient to draw a math-knowledgeable person away from private-sector opportunities.
- tptacek 17y agoI agree with that, for whatever it's worth.
- timwiseman 17y agoStudies have been done (Kohn cites one in "The Folly Of Merit Pay") that show more teachers are driven out of teaching by the unintended negative consequences of performance-based pay than are attracted to it by the prospect of more money. That certainly makes sense, but the question addressed in this article was not quantity but quality. Which one attracts a higher caliber of teacher (for whichever definition of higher caliber is being used at the moment)?
- hristov 17y agoIt is very hard to have incentives and competitive influences in education. It is just the nature of education -- the result of a good or bad education is not immediately obvious. If you buy a TV you will know soon after you use it whether it is a good or a bad TV. Not so much with your kids. Although, a very bad school may be immediately obvious a lot of mediocre ones will not be and they will not be distinguishable from very good ones. So, unfortunately, one cannot use general competition to make schools better. One has to rely on teachers and administrators desire to do good.
- tptacek 17y agoIt's also a well-known factoid that the best developers outperform the worst by a factor of 10, and yet despite huge incentives to develop a reliable scheme to rate developers, none exists. Just because we "need" to segment the good teachers (or developers, or doctors) from the bad doesn't mean we can.
- HistoryInAction 17y agoOne key thing is that students get advanced from grade to grade /no matter what/, unless they drop out. Students have little immediate incentive to work to succeed, and social pressure seems set up to disincentivize students towards learning. One possibility I've thought of is that there should be early separation of students into high and low performers to 'scare' parents into pushing their kids towards the 'high' performance. If you can't succeed, you can't, but if you don't try, you'll never get anywhere. Nothing wrong (and a lot right) with vocational education, but so many kids waste money on a college education that they're not able to take advantage of.
- tptacek 17y agoStudies of social promotion also appear to indicate that holding kids back a grade has worse outcomes than simply moving them forward. Now, it may be that the outcome for those kids is better, but the outcome for their class is worse. Either way, it shows to go you that the simple observations ("they just let the kids finish the grade, even though they don't know the material!") don't carry much insight.