4 ms·
You are hiding in a corner, seemingly without knowing why the theory exists or what it is. Strange as it might sound, but the theory behind GPL with linking was
by belorn 12y ago
You are hiding in a corner, seemingly without knowing why the theory exists or what it is. Strange as it might sound, but the theory behind GPL with linking was not made by Stallman.
Many years ago Steve Jobs asked Stallman if Apple could link some proprietary compiler software with the GPLed GCC. Stallman initially thought it seemed legal, but asked a lawyer whose expertise in law and legal theory naturally surpassed that of Stallman. The lawyer replied that a judge would look at the final product and ask if it was two separate programs, or whether it was "really" one program with differently labeled parts. This lawyer concluded that the product would most likely be seen as a single program in the eyes of a judge and jury, and thus create a single work, i.e. a derivative work, if Apple's proprietary compiler parts and GCC was combined.
This is the basis that forms the legal recommendation that FSF has made regarding copyright and linking. If someone believes that a judge/jury would act differently, they are perfectly free to test it in court. By now it is going to be almost 30 years of industry legal practice in dealing with the question, but in the legal question is as simple as stated above.