3 ms·
I think the real question most people want to know the answer to is: Is one of them a front for homeopathy, anti-vaccinations and/or Scientology, or are they bo
by teddyh 12y ago
I think the real question most people want to know the answer to is: Is one of them a front for homeopathy, anti-vaccinations and/or Scientology, or are they both mostly imperceptibly different degrees of serious research?
Downvoters: Please explain. I have no idea about what any of SBM or EBM is, and I hadn’t even heard about any of them before now. This is genuinely what I what to know when I encounter the terms.
- wanion 12y agoEBM is meant to be serious science, but there's been a real effort to co-opt it for quackery. SBM is an attempt to inject science back into it. The difference comes down to how they treat evidence. For example, homeopathy states that a remedy becomes stronger the more dilute it becomes - i.e. the lower the dose, the stronger the effect. This defies the dose-response relationship between an active ingredient and its effect. Further, it states that even when no more of the active ingredient remains, it can still have an effect. SBM would say homeopathy isn't worth studying because it has no plausibility based on what we know of medicine and physics. EBM would say let's test it and see what we get. The problem is that if you test the same thing enough times, or measure enough variables, and then discard the ones that don't meet your desired outcome, you can gather "evidence" for basically anything. SBM would say weak evidence for a claim like homeopathy is meaningless, as the claim is extraordinary (it overturns physics), so you need stronger evidence than you might accept for a less exceptional claim. EBM doesn't make that judgment, it treats all evidence as equally valid.
- heliumcraft 12y agofor the record: homeopathy does not do well with EBM either.. (as in quality double blind studies)
- spydum 12y agosure, but if researchers can cherry pick the data and studies, they just have to avoid those quality double blind studies. all of a sudden, their meta analysis of # studies shows significance!
- Intermernet 12y agoOne definite data point I can illustrate, through personal experience. There is a treatment for trauma (PTSD etc.) called EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) which has over 20 years of statistical evidence backing up it's efficacy. To date, no-one really knows how it works (there are a few good theories, and hopefully modern neuroscience can help here). Currently, it's "EBM". There is a huge amount of evidence to show it works, but no proven theory as to why. It's not "SBM" yet, as there still isn't a demonstrable mechanism or theory that describes why it works. homeopathy, antivaxers and scientoligists don't even have any evidence to show they work. They don't even count as "EBM".