4 ms·
The validity of scientific knowledge does not depend on replication, it depends on confirmation and agreement. Merely repeating the original experiment might s
by snowwrestler 12y ago
The validity of scientific knowledge does not depend on replication, it depends on confirmation and agreement.
Merely repeating the original experiment might simply repeat the design errors of the original experiment. For example what if I drop a feather a bunch of times and find a value for g (gravitational acceleration) of 3.4 m/s^2? If you drop a similar feather you'll probably get a similar value, but that doesn't make it right.
The real question is not replication, it's whether I've found an accurate value for g. In that respect, science is better advanced if you attempt to confirm this value by designing your own experiment to test it, by dropping something else (a rock, maybe) instead of a feather.
We're well beside the original point of this thread now, but the focus on replication is a bit of a pet peeve of mine.
edit: clarity