6 ms·
Holy heck, $12.5K? That's one heck of a nice bug bounty program Facebook has there. That is likely more than the black market would pay for this, or at least a
by Someone1234 12y ago
Holy heck, $12.5K? That's one heck of a nice bug bounty program Facebook has there. That is likely more than the black market would pay for this, or at least a lot less hassle (plus the black market might have little interest as this cannot be used for hijackings, just trolling/harrassment).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dsacco 12y agoIt's not very useful to compare bug bounty payouts to what the "black market" would pay for a vulnerability. Let's look through the challenges of selling a vulnerability that allows for arbitrary account takeover (much more serious than this): 0. Find the vulnerability. Assume that no one will find it by the time you find a third party buyer. 1. Look for a buyer. If you're not well-connected, you might stumble into an FBI honeypot (a sting operation) because you don't know what you're doing. But let's assume you know what you're doing and you find a buyer. 2. You negotiate a price. You don't receive much more than Facebook would pay you (if they even give you that much) for a few reasons: a. The vulnerability can only be used on Facebook, so it's not vendor agnostic (compare Heartbleed, Shellshock); b. The vulnerability has an extremely small window of capitalization - it will be discovered within a week of use, maybe less. The Facebook incident response team is spectacular. c. You need to figure out a sufficient monetization strategy for distributing malware or spam using profiles that are taken over using this vulnerability. You have a week of use, much less if you try to take over accounts too aggressively. Now you're going up against all of Facebook's other protections - once you have the account, spreading malware will either be algorithmically discovered by Facebook or reported by other users. With an organized crime unit composed of professional hackers, this might pay off. Maybe. And that is for one of the most serious bugs you can find. You're better off just taking what Facebook (generously) gives you. The classical fallacy people fall into is believing that a web application vulnerability is worth much, especially the variety most tech companies have to offer. It's certainly serious, yes, but it's only worth what a market will pay for it. It's worth a lot to Facebook for brand integrity. It's not worth a lot to hackers looking to make money. The only web applications that might be worth real money would be banks or government institutions (or similar platforms). Real money is found in vulnerabilities on desktop clients, especially memory corruption vulnerabilities, or in ubiquitous software that affects servers. You want to be able to compromise a user for use in a botnet or distribute malware to steal their money or personal information. Alternatively, you want to be able to attack, say, 30% of the websites on the internet with a wide variety of options after you get in. Examples include: • Vulnerabilities in Flash. • Vulnerabilities in Python, Ruby or corresponding web frameworks. • Code execution in iOS that allows a jailbreak (most sources indicate the going price for this is $500,000). Other vulnerabilities as well, such as compromising app store receipts or in-app purchase checks. • Vulnerabilities in Android, up to and including code execution. • A game over flaw in any number of ubiquitous software packages used on Linux servers with root access. • A sandbox escape in OS X or Windows (you'll be paid more for Windows but both are lucrative).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pcthrowaway 12y agoIn a week, an attacker with an account-takeover exploit could attack every high-profile celebrity and likely dig up enough dirt on them to get far more than $50,000 in hush money. Or they could go the old-fashioned route and use it to snoop on the plans of wealthy people to kidnap them and hold them for ransom. There are many, many possibilities for making money if you can gain access to anyone's facebook account, even if it is just for a week. $50,000 is not an extraordinarily large compensation for ethically disclosing an exploit of this nature by any means.
- tptacek 12y agoDo you have firsthand or even secondhand knowledge of a market for account takeover bugs where the buyers are monetizing those bugs via celebrity dirt? Do you have knowledge of markets for account takeover where buyers are directly monetizing those bugs at all? I'm not asking if you can hypothesize such a market. I'm asking if you know about one actually existing. It's been suggested to me that there is in fact at least one set of buyers for account takeover bugs. But they aren't monetizing those accounts.
- jessaustin 12y agoIf they aren't monetizing them, can you be more specific about what these hypothetical exploit buyers are doing with the pwned accounts?
- pcthrowaway 12y agoI don't, but I strongly suspect they exist. While it's not my MO, I am quite certain that a blackhat-hacker with an exploit that enables them to compromise anyone's personal account would have the idea to target wealthy/famous people for personal gain. I also don't think it's beyond reason to think they could generate more than $50,000 through malicious means. Doing it without getting caught would be the challenging part, I guess.
- mahyarm 12y agoWhen 1 engineer costs ~$250k+ fully loaded, it isn't that much! Plus they become good future recruiting targets.
- Liuser 12y agoIt's a great incentive to not sell it on the black market.
- nickhalfasleep 12y agoOr when you do find something really exploitable you already have a financial incentive to be good.
- tptacek 12y agoI doubt the "black market" would pay much of anything for this bug, because, like most severe web vulnerabilities, it has no half-life.
- minionslave 12y agoWhat do you mean by "half-life" in this context ?
- patio11 12y agoHalf-life means what it usually does: time until 50% of the thing (vulnerable clients) have evaporated. You can plot out a decay curve. Vulnerabilities are valuable when many clients still exist which can be profitably exploited. The half-life of this bug is ~0. As soon as Facebook becomes aware of it, it is nearly instantly fixed everywhere. This is very not the case if you get e.g. code execution on a version of Java which will take 50 months to completely disappear from the wild.
- Raphmedia 12y agoNo, but imagine the ressources they would have had to throw at the problem if the user had instead decided to delete ALL the photo albums on the site. Or imagine if he would have used the exploit to delete all the photos of a movie launch, etc. The reward is appropriate.
- tptacek 12y agoI understand the reward, but Facebook was buying the incentive for people to look for bugs like this; they weren't competing with the black market.
- itsybitsycoder 12y agoI'm guessing not much? I was under the impression that nothing you delete on Facebook is ever truly deleted, just marked as disabled and hidden. And if they're logging their API calls it should be fairly straightforward to look up which albums were disabled using that one token and switch the flag back.