3 ms·
Well, that's why in-house work tends to come out much better than stuff that's contracted out.
by emodendroket 12y ago
Well, that's why in-house work tends to come out much better than stuff that's contracted out.
- dredmorbius 12y agoSometimes. Sometimes not. It really depends on whose sense of what's relevant succeeds. Sometimes that talent's in house, sometimes it's out-of-house. The real question is whether or not the decisionmakers get in the way or not.
- emodendroket 12y agoThe incentives for in-house work are different and better (like, "let's just check off everything in the contract whether or not it suits the client needs" is not something an employee would say).
- dredmorbius 12y agoAgain, it depends. On the client. On the contractor. On the relationship between the two. On who gets to decide. On the relative competencies of all involved. The worst possible scenario is where a fundamentally incompetent client meets a fundamentally uncaring contractor, who pushes for the latest razzle, flash, and dash (all of which increase downstream contracting potential). It's a "market for bicycles" problem. Very nearly as bad is when you're dealing with an organization with deep hierarchy but little ownership -- nobody within the organization really carries responsibility for the decisions they make, and everyone carries impunity. Literally, immunity from punishment. This is an evolutionary situation of variation without selection (or rather the variation acts on the individual level while selection operates, if it does, on the organization as a whole). Poor decisions happen here regardless of whether design happens in-house or out. The problem isn't one of propriety, but of impunity. Small but focused clients, with ongoing relationships with small but focused contractors, often give you the best results. Here you've got a client which does have a strong sense of accountability, but lacking in the ability to retain dedicated talent. The contractors depend on both their repeat business and word-of-mouth. This often gives rise to some of the best design in terms of overall usability.