3 ms·
I love that report and find it very inspiring (and it gives me an intuition that Haskell has an edge over the other languages), but the methodology is very disa
by the_af 12y ago
I love that report and find it very inspiring (and it gives me an intuition that Haskell has an edge over the other languages), but the methodology is very disappointing:
- The requirements were mostly up to the interpretation of implementors, which more or less decided the scope of their programs.
- All results were self-reported. Even ruling out dishonesty, there are a lot of ways uncontrolled experimenters can report incorrect results.
- Many implementations weren't even runnable.
- No code was run by the reviewers, at all.
I really would love to see a more serious attempt at this experiment (probably with more modern languages).