3 ms·
I'd like to chime in here. The valuable thing isn't individual peer-reviewed papers, it's bodies of peer-reviewed works. "Peer-review" as most people think of
by saalweachter 12y ago
I'd like to chime in here.
The valuable thing isn't individual peer-reviewed papers, it's bodies of peer-reviewed works.
"Peer-review" as most people think of it -- the vetting of papers by a few reviewers before publication -- is the start of the process, not the end. Peer-review is what happens after your paper is published and your peers -- the people who read the papers you publish -- read your paper and discuss your paper and try and succeed or fail to replicate your results. A journal isn't "peer-reviewed" because a couple of schmucks read the paper before publication; that's just the scientific equivalent of Fizz-Buzz to avoid wasting everyone's time with obvious crap. It's "peer-reviewed" because it is widely and critically read by a large number of practitioners in a field.
You should never regard an individual paper uncritically just because it is published. Later, in light of a larger body of research, you might regard a paper as particularly insightful or seminal.
- lotharbot 12y agoThis is a wonderfully clear explanation. Well said. To generalize a little more: science isn't about single pieces of data or single experiments. Science is about the process. Experiment/data -> idea -> experiment/data -> refined idea -> ... until the idea and the data match to the greatest possible degree (a temporary state of affairs, until science in other areas makes it possible to refine measurements even more tightly.) A single paper, even one with solid methodology, extensive data, and clear patterns, is just one part of science. Replication, refinement, methodological improvements, identification of weaknesses, etc. are what make the whole institution of science so powerful.