4 ms·
If he couldn't spend the time to examine it, he should have just said that instead of taking the time to blather about journalistic vs. academic review processe
by notacoward 12y ago
If he couldn't spend the time to examine it, he should have just said that instead of taking the time to blather about journalistic vs. academic review processes. Clearly he did have the time; he just used it poorly.
- sanderjd 12y agoYour argument is interesting, but it seems to boil down to dismissing the entire system of peer reviewed journals. If they can't be appealed to, and everything needs to be independently researched based on personal expertise, then they have no purpose. Would you agree with that?
- mmusson 12y agoI took his meaning to be that appealing to peer reviewed journals as an "authority" is what is wrong. The value of the peer review system is the rigorous process and the continuing search for the truth.