2 ms·
The mirror twins of ad hominem and ad verecundiam (appeal to authority) are always fallacies, regardless of person or circumstances. To say that certain people
by notacoward 12y ago
The mirror twins of ad hominem and ad verecundiam (appeal to authority) are always fallacies, regardless of person or circumstances. To say that certain people should get away with them is itself an appeal to authority. In logic, science, or debate, the identity of the person making or disputing a claim is irrelevant. If Clausen had a concern about the data, he should have said so. If he had a concern about the reasoning applied to that data, he should have said so. That would have been "demanding rigor" as you put it, but he did neither. Instead he addressed identity, and that's where he came off as snotty.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jakevn 12y agoHe did have a concern about the data. His concern that was it was not peer-reviewed. Had the data come from someone with a proven track record in the field, he may have found it worth his time to peer review it himself. Appeal to authority is not always a fallacy. It would have been fallacious if he was outright denying or accepting a hypothesis as being the logical conclusion based on one's standing. All that I read from it, however, was that he had a hard time believing it, and would not spend the time to look into the data personally, but that it should be reviewed. I don't think it's illogical to take more seriously the hypothesis of someone with a proven track record of good research.
- notacoward 12y agoIf he couldn't spend the time to examine it, he should have just said that instead of taking the time to blather about journalistic vs. academic review processes. Clearly he did have the time; he just used it poorly.
- sanderjd 12y agoYour argument is interesting, but it seems to boil down to dismissing the entire system of peer reviewed journals. If they can't be appealed to, and everything needs to be independently researched based on personal expertise, then they have no purpose. Would you agree with that?
- mmusson 12y agoI took his meaning to be that appealing to peer reviewed journals as an "authority" is what is wrong. The value of the peer review system is the rigorous process and the continuing search for the truth.
- aamar 12y ago> In logic, science, or debate, the identity of the person making or disputing a claim is irrelevant. Are you describing logic/science/debate as you believe it to be or as you believe it should be? If the latter, are you suggesting ending peer review?
- Jach 12y agoAppeal to authority may be a fallacy in strictly formal logical reasoning, but it's trivially shown in probabilistic reasoning (which is the core of scientific reasoning -- reasoning under uncertainty) that if the data supports experts being right in disagreements on claims more often than non-experts, then an expert making a claim provides at least weak evidence in favor compared to a non-expert's opposition, knowing nothing else about the claim's veracity. Unless you're arguing by trading Coq proofs, it might help to consider a probabilistic approach for natural language arguments with degrees of informality and stop fighting over the various fallacies that don't really apply outside of strict formal logic arguments and instead spend time seeking the truth. For more, see: http://www.gwern.net/docs/statistics/2003-korb.pdf http://www.gwern.net/docs/statistics/2003-korb.pdf http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mike_Oaksford/publication/6199092_The_rationality_of_informal_argumentation_a_Bayesian_approach_to_reasoning_fallacies/links/0c96051e9a3d941970000000.pdf http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mike_Oaksford/publicatio... http://www.pfeifer-research.de/pdf/pfeifer08rh.pdf http://www.pfeifer-research.de/pdf/pfeifer08rh.pdf I can see how Clausen comes off as snotty. But his response is pretty neutral, even if he praises peer review as a filter beyond its actual merits. He sees a lack of appropriate effort to establish the claim from a nobody, why should he not be skeptical of such claims in general? It's the same heuristic people like Aaronson make on being highly skeptical of the latest P==NP or P!=NP proof uploaded to arxiv.