5 ms·
I wonder if this guy has actually worked in the "enterprise" before because it sure isn't what he is talking about. Companies like Facebook, Soundcloud etc are
by threeseed 12y ago
I wonder if this guy has actually worked in the "enterprise" before because it sure isn't what he is talking about. Companies like Facebook, Soundcloud etc are nothing more than bigger startups. Go work for a bank sometime and then tell me they are comparable to Spotify.
As for Go. What it really needs is a great story around Java integration. JDBC drivers and libraries need to just work out of the box. Then you can talk about building cute little micro services.
And Scala's toolchain is pretty simple at least with something like Play.
- frowaway001 12y agoAgree. I also wonder what this inferiority complex "hurr durr, $X is not written in Go, therefore we need to duplicate it in Go!!!" is about ...
- slimsag 12y agoI don't think it's _always an_ inferiority complex. I've personally run into many situations in which porting a lib to Go is easier -- and more efficient -- than my brain's context switching between multiple languages in order to fix issues with the original lib.
- Zikes 12y agoLook, it's pretty obvious from your comments that you're not a fan of Go, but if you can come to terms with the fact that some people enjoy languages you do not (or their use is mandated by their work environment) then you'll also be able to understand that they would also like certain tools and libraries available to them in that language. It's not about recreating everything in Go "just because", it's about being a Go developer and wanting those tools to be available to you.
- Retra 12y agoThis highlights a bigger problem: why should you have to reimplement the same idea hundreds of times if what you already want to do already exists?
- Zikes 12y agoI don't look at it as reinventing the wheel, any more than one would consider the advent of new languages and technologies a reinvention. They're iterations on the concept, bringing that concept into a new environment to be further refined or built upon. Other threads in this discussion bring up Finagle's shortcomings, partly due to certain features not being addressed or included by Finagle's authors due to them being low priority. In that case what you want may not already exist, but may work as inspiration for another incarnation.
- simonw 12y agoI once saw Douglas Crockford, when asked about JSON in comparison to XML, say "The great thing about reinventing the wheel is that sometimes you get a round one".
- cmelbye 12y agoHe led his article with a distinction between the "enterprise" that you refer to, and the "modern enterprise" (Twitter, Facebook, Google, ...) that he discusses in his article. This article specifically focuses on the problems of those companies.
- threeseed 12y agoNo he talked about enterprises in terms of IT companies. What I am referring to are enterprises that aren't in the bubble of the IT industry e.g. banks, insurance companies, retail etc. You know what the rest of the world defines enterprise to be. You have different problems and pressures when you don't have hundreds/thousands of highly experienced engineers.
- sagichmal 12y ago"IT companies" like Google, Amazon, Twitter, Netflix, and SoundCloud are the ones driving technical conversations and advancing the state of the art. Banks, insurance companies, and retail outfits aren't, and haven't been for a decade or more.
- pjmlp 12y agoExcept that Banks, insurance companies, and retail outfits is where the real money is. Google, Amazon, Twitter, Netflix, and SoundCloud are for engineeers living in Silicon Valey.
- cmelbye 12y agoI can't tell if you're trolling or serious. Retail is where the money is, but Amazon, a Seattle-based company, is for engineers living in Silicon Valley? How is the sector at all relevant? (Software is eating the world, and all that.)
- Zikes 12y agoWalmart and Sam's Club are both actively developing in Go.