2 ms·
Which ethical rules exactly did they violate? Here is the Honor Code from the university[1] I don't see any mentions of the words "share", "distribute", "post
by Alupis 12y ago
Which ethical rules exactly did they violate?
Here is the Honor Code from the university[1]
I don't see any mentions of the words "share", "distribute", "post", "online", "github", etc.
What I do see, is a lot of talk about plagiarizing other student's work and passing it off as your own.
The github repos did not do this -- other students did this. You punish the students who commit the act of plagiarism -- not the source. You don't ban a book because somebody plagiarized it.
[1] http://cs.illinois.edu/current-students/undergraduates/policies-and-procedures-0/honor-code-and-academic-integrity http://cs.illinois.edu/current-students/undergraduates/polic...
- akerl_ 12y agoFrom that link: "As described in the Student Code, aiding someone else's cheating also constitutes cheating. Leaving your program in plain sight or leaving a computer without logging out, thereby leaving your programs open to copying, may constitute cheating depending upon the circumstances. Consequently, you should always take care to prevent others from copying your programs, as it certainly leaves you open to accusations of cheating."
- Alupis 12y ago> thereby leaving your programs open to copying, may constitute cheating depending upon the circumstances Did the university contact each student and request to have the student remove the repo? Unlikely given the sheer volume of repos in the takedown request. Irregardless, the University should have measures to deal with this internally if they felt so strongly about this cheating rule.
- akerl_ 12y agoTheir rules don't state that they need to. Had they chosen to enforce their ethics code internally and take internal action against the students, they'd have been within the bounds of that policy. That said, they didn't do that: they used the DMCA. Their use of the DMCA is a strange choice in my opinion, but is likewise valid if the repos contain original work created by the university as part of the problem set.
- digler990 12y ago"Irregardless" is not a word.
- dragonwriter 12y agoMerriam-Webster disagrees with you. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/irregardless http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/irregardless
- Aradalf 12y ago"Use regardless instead." Direct quote from your link.